T. Rowe Price makes a $190 million misstep

T. Rowe Price makes a $190 million misstep
Wrong vote in 2013 on Dell proxy costs shareholders.
JUN 06, 2016
T. Rowe Price is discovering that when you vote the wrong way in a buyout deal, you repent at leisure — and with millions of dollars. The Baltimore mutual fund giant made a rare error by voting in favor of the 2013 buyout of Dell by founder Michael Dell, according to the Wall Street Journal. The company had opposed the deal, saying it undervalued the 30 million shares held in T. Rowe Price mutual funds. T. Rowe could have collected about $190 million in the settlement, but its vote disqualified the company from suing for more money. Mr. Dell and his partners, Silver Lake Partners, will have to pay some investors about $35 million in the wake of the June 1 ruling by a Delaware special court. The ruling is particularly embarrassing for T. Rowe Price, which asked Delaware Judge Travis Laster to appraise its shares in February 2014. At the time, the company said it had not voted for the deal. But in August of that year, it reported that it had voted for the deal to federal regulators. The ruling seems to leave the company with few options. “We're in the process of reviewing the court's opinions and considering our options,” T. Rowe Price spokesman Brian Lewbart said. Fund companies vote in thousands of proxies, a routine but administratively complex undertaking. “T. Rowe Price has taken a lot of back-office effort and tried to make them more efficient,” said Todd Rosenbluth, director of ETF and mutual fund research for S&P Global Market Intelligence. “Their eye wasn't on the ball properly.” Normally, mutual fund companies tend to be passive in proxy votes, preferring to sell shares rather than engage in proxy battles. Investors in T. Rowe price funds probably shouldn't be waiting for a big fat bump from any adjustment from T. Rowe Price. Assuming a payout of $190 million for about 30 million shares, investors would get about $6.33 a share in compensation. But it would be unusual for any fund to have more than 2% to 5% of its assets in any one stock. “Those are well-diversified funds,” Mr. Rosenbluth said. “Anything you're missing out on is unfortunate as a shareholder, but the error probably didn't hurt the funds too much.” Citigroup, in a research note, said it was most likely that the fund company, rather than the individual funds, would foot the tab. They estimate the mistake would cost the stock about 80 cents a share, but doubts the payout would affect the stock in the short or long term. And, while the mistake modestly hurts the T. Rowe Price brand, its efforts to do the right thing by shareholders offsets some of the damage, Citi said.

Latest News

Osaic CEO says market gains inflate LPL's Commonwealth retention
Osaic CEO says market gains inflate LPL's Commonwealth retention

Jamie Price says LPL shifted its Commonwealth target from advisors to assets, letting 16 months of growth mask departures

Boomers crave retirement protection but few act on it: Nationwide
Boomers crave retirement protection but few act on it: Nationwide

80% of Baby Boomers prefer guaranteed income over growth investments, yet only 17% hold an annuity, leaving protection gaps for financial advisors to close

Commonwealth Financial’s move or conversion to LPL a success, company declares
Commonwealth Financial’s move or conversion to LPL a success, company declares

“Even with all the work done before hand, this is still a bit stressful,” one advisor said. 

Cary Street Partners buys Townsend Asset Management in Raleigh push
Cary Street Partners buys Townsend Asset Management in Raleigh push

Richmond-based RIA lands a 45-year-old North Carolina wealth management team as small-firm acquisitions slow nationwide

401(k) prospecting gets AI upgrade with WealthFeed form data update
401(k) prospecting gets AI upgrade with WealthFeed form data update

Drawing from Form 5500 filings, the platform scores 780,000 retirement plans and maps warm introductions as advisors chase the DC-to-wealth bridge

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.