The unofficial science behind 'sell in May' market phenomenom

The unofficial science behind 'sell in May' market phenomenom
The investment strategy has only outperformed buy and hold 24% of the time since the end of 1990, according to S&P Global.
MAY 11, 2016
If you sell your clients' stocks in May and go away through October, you'll probably hurt their performance. But there's actually some causation to the correlation between stock returns and the half-year that started this month. The Standard and Poor's 500 stock index has averaged a 9.9% annual gain in the 25 years since the end of 1990, according to Sam Stovall, U.S. equity strategist for S&P Global. (That's with dividends reinvested). Had you sold all your stocks in May and invested the proceeds in three-month Treasury bills through October, you would have earned an average annual rate of 8.9%, albeit with much lower volatility, Mr. Stovall said. But Jeffrey Hirsch, editor of the Stock Trader's Almanac, notes that in election years, May ranks 11th in monthly performance for the Dow Jones Industrial Average. September remains the worst month of all, and five of the past 10 bear markets have ended in October. “Since 1950, 'sell in May does beat buy and hold,' Mr. Hirsch said. “And it's not just about beating buy and hold, it's about avoiding the times when the market is likely to have its worst days. Avoiding the worst days is more important than getting the best days." LACK OF INFLOWS Is there any particular reason why the May though October period tends to be so dreadful? “It's not capital flight in summer — it's lack of inflows,” Mr. Stovall said. In the beginning of the year, pension funds tend to add to their investments, and those who get tax refunds typically get them early in the year. In addition, technology stocks tend to do particularly well in cold weather, in part because of the Christmas season and in part because many IT departments have to spend their budget by the end of the year or see the money go elsewhere. In contrast, flows to mutual funds tend to tail off after the first few months of the year. College tuition bills come due in August. And by September and October, many funds are busily remaking their portfolios, jettisoning losers and buying winners so their holdings look smart for the end of the year — a practice known as “window dressing.” Mr. Stovall found another unsettling thing about the “sell in May” strategy: It has only outperformed buy and hold 24% of the time since the end of 1990. But some variants have been more successful: • Buy bonds in May. Investing in the Barclay's Aggregate bond index from May through October boosted returns to an 11.3% aggregate rate, and cut the portfolio's standard deviation from 18.1 for buy and hold to 11.9. The strategy has beaten the buy-and-hold strategy just 44% of the time, however. • Buy low volatility in May. Jumping to the S&P Low Volatility index from May through October boosted returns to 11.9% annually and cut standard deviation to 15.0. Its success rate against buy-and-hold was 56%. • Buy health care and consumer staples in May. Those two defensive sectors hold up well in punk markets, and boost the “sell in May” strategy's return to 13.1%, Mr. Stovall said. Standard deviation fell to 14.1, and the strategy had a 60% success rate. Low volatility stocks are now more expensive than their historical norms, thanks to the recent popularity of the strategy. But the S&P Low Volatility index is rebalanced every quarter, with overly hyper stocks getting bounced from the index. Those stocks, typically, are the most overpriced. Selling stocks every six months, of course, is something few advisers would do. You'd rack a big tax bill and goose your trading costs as well. Nevertheless, the market's performance in the worst six months does have some rationale behind it. “You can't just say it's investors focusing more on their tans than their portfolios,” Mr. Stovall said.

Latest News

Osaic discloses conflict tied to overlapping Envestnet ownership
Osaic discloses conflict tied to overlapping Envestnet ownership

Osaic’s Form ADV says majority owner Reverence Capital’s stake in Envestnet gives the firm and its advisors an incentive to recommend Envestnet programs. Reverence and Bain Capital backs both firms.

IRS hands down final auto enrollment rules for new 401(k), 403(b) plans
IRS hands down final auto enrollment rules for new 401(k), 403(b) plans

Treasury’s final SECURE 2.0 regulations give plan sponsors flexibility, though Vanguard calls for existing plans to face the mandate too

Embattled Nvidia faces SEC probe as California attorney general mulls action
Embattled Nvidia faces SEC probe as California attorney general mulls action

Regulators zero in on disclosures after Jensen Huang’s exit, while ETF data shows how deeply the fallout reaches client portfolios

FINRA penalizes Spartan Capital $3.18 million, charges pre-IPO fraud, Reg BI violations
FINRA penalizes Spartan Capital $3.18 million, charges pre-IPO fraud, Reg BI violations

Meanwhile, Spartan’s owner and former CEO John Lowry was suspended from the securities industry for two years.

Advisor moves: &Partners lands $1.3B multigenerational team as Merrill adds $1.7B
Advisor moves: &Partners lands $1.3B multigenerational team as Merrill adds $1.7B

Merrill recruits from UBS, Morgan Stanley and Edward Jones as an Oklahoma credit union moves its $430M wealth program to Ameriprise

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.