Third Avenue had no exit plan in place

Third Avenue had no exit plan in place
After peaking way back in 2014 and declining ever since, the high-yield bond market finally has made national news over the past week with the very high profile blow up of the Third Avenue Focused Credit Fund.
DEC 17, 2015
This was not some fly-by-night little fund or fund family. It's a small, mainstream mutual fund family, and the fund itself had more than $3 billion in assets in 2014. Last week, after massive withdrawals, the fund announced it was closing and that shareholders could not redeem their shares for cash anytime soon. Third Avenue was going to conduct an "orderly" liquidation. Good luck with that. Over the past 20 years, my peers and I have often discussed this exact scenario. What happens when there is a mass exodus in an illiquid asset class like junk bonds? If Third Avenue was a closed end fund or exchange traded fund, sellers would simply drive the price lower and lower until sufficient buyers came in, presumably when the share price of the closed end fund or ETF was significantly below the value of the underlying assets in the fund. In other words, they would trade at a discount to the net asset value of the fund. In Third Avenue's case, it is an open ended fund that issues more and more shares to meet investor demand. When redemptions swell, the manager chooses what to sell and when. And it's unlikely that securities are sold on a pro rata basis. As 10 fund's assets collapsed, my sense is that the fund manager sold most or all of the bonds that were easier to sell, i.e., liquid, hoping that he could stem the tide and high-yield bonds would stabilize or even bounce. When the liquidations never ceased, the fund was probably left with only garbage instead of the well diversified portfolio it had weeks, months or quarters earlier. In other words, at the detriment of the shareholders who stuck by the fund, they were left with illiquid crap. This raises a whole series of questions regarding the fund manager's and fund company's fiduciary responsibility to its shareholders. Clearly, they had absolutely no plan for a mass exodus, like disaster planning for many firms in my space. How could they allow the fund manager to sell the better quality bonds and turn the fund into a heap of dung? How could they penalize investors like this? While I am sure they will hide behind the nonsensical legalese of the prospectus, this is a travesty. Paul Schatz is president of Heritage Capital.

Latest News

The hidden currency risk in global investing: what advisors need to know
The hidden currency risk in global investing: what advisors need to know

For those seeking international exposure amid economic uncertainty, understanding the impact of the US dollar's strength over other currencies is more important than ever.

CFP Board warns of tax "tipping point" as TCJA expiration puts financial plans at risk
CFP Board warns of tax "tipping point" as TCJA expiration puts financial plans at risk

With nearly nine in 10 seeing danger to clients' retirement income and legacy plans, among others, CFP professionals are urging strategic planning pivots and tax perks for advice-seekers.

Fed Day focus fades as Trump keeps stock markets watching
Fed Day focus fades as Trump keeps stock markets watching

As policymakers convene for their latest two-day meeting, investors are shifting their attention from elevated interest rates to growth concerns and tariff worries.

IRS eases off on some audits with retrenchments giving way to AI
IRS eases off on some audits with retrenchments giving way to AI

While he hasn't laid out a clear plan, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has gone on record touting "the great AI revolution" in improving the agency's tax collections and customer service.

More than three-quarters of advisors to embrace fee models by 2026, Cerulli says
More than three-quarters of advisors to embrace fee models by 2026, Cerulli says

Momentum continues for fee-based compensation as BD advisors ditch commissions and alternative compensation schemes emerge to lure diverse clientele.

SPONSORED Beyond the all-in-one: Why specialization is key in wealth tech

In an industry of broad solutions, firms like intelliflo prove 'you just need tools that play well together'

SPONSORED Record growth: Interval funds emerge as key players in alternative investments

Blue Vault Alts Summit highlights the role of liquidity-focused funds in reshaping advisor strategies