Don't discourage potential savers with misleading math

Don't discourage potential savers with misleading math
Scolding Americans about lost opportunity only discourages them from starting now to save and invest.
APR 12, 2023

How much is tomorrow worth? The time value of money is one of the hardest ideas for consumers to understand, and one of the most important. Delayed gratification is not much fun, at least today.

That makes it all the more important for advisers to be crystal clear about how clients — current and potential — will likely reap returns. Interest-bearing accounts that deliver metronomic compounded returns aren't the same as market accounts that count on the long arc of time, plus dividends and other underlying factors, to buoy results that outpace inflation and fees.

“It’s a fundamental mathematical misunderstanding used by financial advisors when they try to project growth in financial assets,” said Michael Finke, professor of wealth management with the American College of Financial Services. “People use a rate of return to project growth in savings over time. They have an idea that if you invest in riskier assets you’ll get, say, an 8% return. But that’s not 8% growth.”

Many factors play into this misleading math, Finke said. Stocks are much more volatile than bonds — and more volatility means a bigger difference between average returns and actual investment growth over time (known as geometric returns). For example, an investor will need a 25% return to make up a loss of 20%. That’s why a 20-year S&P 500 investment made during any month of 1999 or 2000 never grew to an amount higher than long-term Treasury bonds despite often having a higher average annual return. Stocks have to work hard to overcome volatility, he explained.

There you have it: Don't use compound-return logic to make a case for long-term investing. It's more complicated than that, and it's just not accurate.

Besides, inflation and fees also skew results. Don't pretend they aren't factors.

It's essential to clearly delineate interest-driven results from market-driven results. Americans very much need to understand the difference, as they remind themselves of the value of insured bank accounts.

Look no further than the Securities and Exchange Commission for how to do it right. Its handy compound interest calculator clearly labels an interest-rate field and makes no pretense of estimating investing returns. Thank you, SEC, for this proper example of expectation management!

And the “miracle of compound interest” is swiftly toppled by the harsh realities of retirement calendars. Just ask this year’s newly or nearly retired, who are sick about the market retreat that has mowed down their investment returns, forcing them into painful financial and lifestyle decisions.

Yes, investing early, generally speaking, should pay off. But it’s not a sure thing, so don’t use sure-thing terminology to prove the point.

Worst of all, abusing compounding terminology undermines the message that Americans really, really do need to invest early and regularly.

Some do, and some didn't, couldn't, or wouldn't.

Many Americans are realizing in midlife that the time value of money isn't something they can make up.

But if they get the message that they're hopelessly behind, they'll just give up.

What they need to hear is that it’s never too late. You can’t make up for lost time, but most Americans can find a way forward, from wherever they are. If they have to catch up now, they have many more options than they did decades ago. Side hustles abound. Low-fee vehicles speed net return. Employer programs can accelerate retirement savings.

The best time to start is always now. Hope, not judgment, is what persuades people to do better by their future selves.

Bonds offer more than portfolio protection after a step-up in rates

Latest News

Why UHNW clients are rethinking inheritance before death
Why UHNW clients are rethinking inheritance before death

Kate Maier of Wealth Enhancement explains why UHNW clients aren’t waiting until death to give.

Retirement plan hardship withdrawals rise as 401(k) loan activity climbs
Retirement plan hardship withdrawals rise as 401(k) loan activity climbs

Bank of America data shows near-term financial pressure mounting even as average balances gain nearly 10% since year-end.

Advisor moves: Atlas tops $1B as Wells Fargo, UBS add bank veterans
Advisor moves: Atlas tops $1B as Wells Fargo, UBS add bank veterans

Wells Fargo adds two bank-channel recruits, UBS lands a JPMorgan Chase veteran, and a multi-family office lifts Atlas past $1B

Advisor mom’s son used her password to log into clients’ accounts, sell deal with conflicts, according to Washington state
Advisor mom’s son used her password to log into clients’ accounts, sell deal with conflicts, according to Washington state

“The state comes down on you in years when you make 40% returns for clients,” said Bill Swayne, the advisor and son of Candace Swayne.

Osaic in talks with Anthropic as AI reshapes advisor workforce
Osaic in talks with Anthropic as AI reshapes advisor workforce

The Independent broker-dealer giant has had “active conversations” with the Claude maker, which is days away from its expected IPO

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.