Insurance regulators flubbing their jobs

OCT 01, 2007
State insurance regulators have only themselves to blame for a renewed push by parts of the insurance industry for federal insurance agent registration and an optional charter from Congress for insurance companies. For years, the industry has been complaining about the lack of uniformity in regulation across the states. According to a study by the American Council of Life Insurers, this lack of uniformity costs the industry — and ultimately customers — $432 million a year. But state regulators have failed to respond to the complaints and have failed to take any steps to harmonize their regulations to any significant degree. Insurers still must deal with different fees, different renewal schedules, different continuing-education requirements, etc. Most of the differences should be easy to eliminate so that insurance licensing is less of an operational burden and less expensive for firms that operate in more than one state. While some insurers see hope in a federal approach, others prefer a coordinated state effort. They oppose even the option of a federal charter, concerned, no doubt, that the mere availability of an alternative eventually will lead to the federal charter's becoming the default choice. They argue that despite frustrations, state regulators — often because they are local — are probably easier to deal with than federal regulators. What they don't say, of course, is that they want to preserve the enormous political clout they wield in the states. Coming from the same don't-rock-the-boat school, state insurance commissioners oppose federal chartering because their states might lose revenue. Maybe more importantly, their jobs would become less important or perhaps even disappear — though when was the last time you saw a government job eliminated? The bottom line is that the system is inefficient and hurts consumers. Harmonizing state regulations would save between $268 million and $377 million a year, the Washington-based ACLI estimates. That wouldn't eliminate the entire $432 million burden imposed by the lack of uniformity, but it would help. The primary role of state regulators is to protect the insurance consumer. But if the cost of that protection is padded by more than a quarter of a billion dollars a year, simply because regulators can't coordinate their regulations, they aren't doing a very good job. If state insurance commissioners don't get their act together — and soon — Congress should step in and establish an optional federal insurance charter and a federal registration program for agents. Competition is good for the private sector, so maybe a little in-tragovernmental competition will prod state insurance regulators to become more responsive and do the right thing for the people they are supposed to protect.

Latest News

AI 'leadership swirl' distracts wealth execs from growth, says Bridge CEO
AI 'leadership swirl' distracts wealth execs from growth, says Bridge CEO

Eddie Brown says RIA executives need AI built for strategy and execution, not just advisor productivity

RIA moves: Summit, UWP deals keep founders in charge; SagePoint adds RISE
RIA moves: Summit, UWP deals keep founders in charge; SagePoint adds RISE

Independent advisors in Colorado, Texas and Arkansas join larger wealth management platforms through acquisitions and partnerships

SEC censures Pacific West sales agent but declines industry bar
SEC censures Pacific West sales agent but declines industry bar

The enforcement division wanted a full bar - the Commission went lighter

CW Advisors buys $920M Woburn RIA, its seventh deal under Osaic
CW Advisors buys $920M Woburn RIA, its seventh deal under Osaic

Welch brothers’ 93 Financial Group gives the Osaic-owned RIA a fifth greater Boston office, days after a $1.6B triple acquisition

Shareholder sues Anson Funds over alleged $165.9M in short-swing profits
Shareholder sues Anson Funds over alleged $165.9M in short-swing profits

The hedge fund group allegedly held a financing 'vice grip' over the company

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.