Investors are often mistaken about which strategies make a portfolio last

APR 04, 2008
By  Bloomberg
Most people have a basic misconception about how to invest after they retire, thinking that a conservative portfolio is the best protection against the risk of running out of money. In reality, financial advisers say, the key to making a client’s money last as long as they do is the annual rate at which they tap the portfolio. The importance of the annual-withdrawal rate is the big difference between building a nest egg and emptying it, said Christine Fahlund, a senior financial planner and vice president at T. Rowe Price Investment Services Inc. in Baltimore. Often, new retirees are shocked to learn how little they can safely withdraw each year from a portfolio that must last two or three decades. Since the late 1990s, independent studies using both historical market data and Monte Carlo projections of future market scenarios have shown that even with optimal investment returns, retirees who take more than 6% a year from their portfolio over a 30-year period run a significant risk of running out of money. The studies consistently have shown that the most prudent withdrawal rate in retirement is 4% of the initial portfolio, plus inflation. For example: If you have a $500,000 portfolio, you withdraw $20,000 the first year. If the consumer price index rises 4% that year, you withdraw $20,800 ($20,000 plus 4%) in year two. If the CPI rises 2% the following year, your next withdrawal is $21,216 ($20,800 plus 2%) and so on. “New retirees always come in thinking they should change their allocation,” said Ross Levin, a certified financial planner and president of Accredited Investors Inc. in Edina, Minn. Often, they don’t realize how much of their portfolio is already in fixed-income equivalents, he said. “Social Security, a defined benefit pension and a paid-off house are all bondlike instruments,” Mr. Levin said. And they want to protect themselves against the loss of principal, even if it means losing purchasing power, he said. Like most advisers, Mr. Levin thinks that that is a fundamental error. Healthy retirees need to invest for total return, just as they did when they were working, because they face decades of inflation. “In today’s environment, a ‘riskless’ 10-year Treasury yields 3.5% — a virtual guarantee to lose money on an after-inflation, after-tax basis,” Mr. Levin said. The upside of a portfolio with a 40% to 60% stock allocation is its potential growth; the downside, of course, is potentially stomach-churning losses. In volatile times like these, a retiree’s wisest course isn’t to change his or her allocation but to reduce the annual-withdrawal rate, Ms. Fahlund said. And that isn’t easy to explain, she said. “If you don’t have ultrawealthy clients, you have to repeat the spending discussion a million times. It’s very hard,” Ms. Fahlund said. “You’ve created a relationship with the client; there’s empathy, understanding, rapport,” she said. “It’s hard to say you can’t spend that much.” Still, Ms. Fahlund said, the solution isn’t to avoid market volatility but to create a long-term strategy that recognizes the inevitable bumps in the road. One very popular approach is the two-bucket portfolio: The first bucket is a cash flow reserve account funded with two years’ worth of living expenses; the second bucket is invested for total return. You take pro-rata annual withdrawals from the cash flow bucket, refilling it as you re-balance the total-return bucket, said Harold Evensky, a certified financial planner and the president of Evensky & Katz Welath Management in Coral Gables, Fla. With this strategy, you hope to avoid having to tap the total-return bucket in a bear market, thus giving your stock holdings a chance to recover. After the recovery, you refill the liquidity bucket. “It’s much easier for a client to take market volatility in stride when he can see a couple of years of cash flow on his account statement,” Mr. Evensky said.

Latest News

Most retirees are now carrying credit card debt
Most retirees are now carrying credit card debt

Over half of people retiree sooner than expected, and rising costs due to inflation, along with unexpected expenses, are leading a growing proportion of retirees to turn to credit cards, EBRI found.

Corient, formerly CI Private Wealth, targets 2026 for IPO
Corient, formerly CI Private Wealth, targets 2026 for IPO

During the third quarter, Corient completed the acquisitions of two firms.

Trump's second term poses fresh risk to ESG investing
Trump's second term poses fresh risk to ESG investing

The president-elect's policies, mirroring the playbook he used eight years ago, creates challenges for the already declining space

Not all advisors on bitcoin bandwagon, despite record returns
Not all advisors on bitcoin bandwagon, despite record returns

Bitcoin may be hitting all-time highs, but that's not fazing some advisors who still view the cryptocurrency with skepticism.

Raymond James nabs more Edward Jones advisors in Washington
Raymond James nabs more Edward Jones advisors in Washington

The wealth management giant has bolstered its independent advisor arm again with the latest additions in the Pacific Northwest.

SPONSORED Out with the old and in with the new: a 50% private markets portfolio

A great man died recently, but this did not make headlines. In fact, it barely even made the news. Maybe it’s because many have already mourned the departure of his greatest legacy: the 60/40 portfolio.

SPONSORED Destiny Wealth Partners: RIA Team of the Year shares keys to success

Discover the award-winning strategies behind Destiny Wealth Partners' client-centric approach.