Is Big Inevitable, or Just Bad?

The giant firm conundrum: is it possible to create scale and still stay entrepreneurial?
OCT 30, 2009
In the last month, I've met with multi-million dollar producers from all of the major firms. On one hand, there is a lasting bitterness at the disintegration of the wealth they had in their company's stocks. On the other hand, there is a feeling of hopelessness because they fear that there is no place to move to, and if they do, that place will be consolidated as well. “Sarch,” one multi-million dollar producer said, “I have no loyalty to this place. They have written me a check to stay, but I would love to know where else I could go. And if I do, what assurances do I have that I won't end up at the same place I left?” To his point, Morgan Stanley recruited a slew of Smith Barney Advisors in 2008 only to become Morgan Stanley Smith Barney in 2009. Smith Barney, Merrill Lynch, Wachovia, Legg Mason, Prudential Securities, Advest, McDonald Investments, AG Edwards, Piper Jaffray With all of these firms disappearing as independent firms in such a short time, it's easy to be cynical and say that big is inevitable; everyone will consolidate sooner or later. Big firms always bragged that their product lines were better, that their technology was superior, that they have more scale and therefore better profit margins, that their brand names have value in retaining clients. But can you keep your Advisors happy in such a big environment? Senior management at the Biggest Firms, here are your challenges: 1. Since you are so big, each individual producer feels less important to his or her branch, his or her region, and to the firm as a whole. 2. Since you are so big, you must manage to your least common denominator; the rules for your most experienced Branch Managers are the same as they are for the raw rookie Branch Managers. In order to stay “compliant” with so many Advisors, you must assume that ever Advisor is doing something wrong, and they must prove themselves to be right, rather than assuming that they are doing what's right in the first place. 3. With almost all key decisions made from the top, the perception is that you have lost the entrepreneurial spirit and flexibility that attracted your best Advisors to you in the first place. The local office, closest to the field, has less and less autonomy on a day to day basis. 4. Fewer support people in the branch and at the home office means that Advisors have less time to spend with prospects and clients, and less time to figure out how to manage their clients' money. Next blog: How big firms can start behaving small, and the smaller firm advantages and problems

Latest News

Osaic CEO says market gains inflate LPL's Commonwealth retention
Osaic CEO says market gains inflate LPL's Commonwealth retention

Jamie Price says LPL shifted its Commonwealth target from advisors to assets, letting 16 months of growth mask departures

Boomers crave retirement protection but few act on it: Nationwide
Boomers crave retirement protection but few act on it: Nationwide

80% of Baby Boomers prefer guaranteed income over growth investments, yet only 17% hold an annuity, leaving protection gaps for financial advisors to close

Commonwealth Financial’s move or conversion to LPL a success, company declares
Commonwealth Financial’s move or conversion to LPL a success, company declares

“Even with all the work done before hand, this is still a bit stressful,” one advisor said. 

Cary Street Partners buys Townsend Asset Management in Raleigh push
Cary Street Partners buys Townsend Asset Management in Raleigh push

Richmond-based RIA lands a 45-year-old North Carolina wealth management team as small-firm acquisitions slow nationwide

401(k) prospecting gets AI upgrade with WealthFeed form data update
401(k) prospecting gets AI upgrade with WealthFeed form data update

Drawing from Form 5500 filings, the platform scores 780,000 retirement plans and maps warm introductions as advisors chase the DC-to-wealth bridge

SPONSORED The new retirement challenge: Preparing for a longer future

Advisors are broadening the conversation beyond savings to help clients prepare for the realities of longer lives

SPONSORED Best Practices for Engaging Women Around Alternatives

Growing wealth, evolving priorities, and untapped opportunities are reshaping how women approach long-term investing.