Let's not rush to arbitration judgment

The North American Securities Administrators Association Inc. and the Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association want to remove industry arbitrators from securities arbitration panels, arguing that the presence of industry representatives makes the panels inherently unfair.
OCT 29, 2007
The North American Securities Administrators Association Inc. and the Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association want to remove industry arbitrators from securities arbitration panels, arguing that the presence of industry representatives makes the panels inherently unfair. They say that using only public arbitrators would make the panels truly neutral. But wouldn't that create a bias against the securities industry? Certainly, it is only natural for public arbitrators to sympathize with an investor alleging wrongdoing by a wealthy financial firm. But what about cases where contentious investors inflate or fabricate a claim because a deep-pocketed firm makes an inviting target? At present, the system seems balanced. In cases using three arbitrators (usually those involving claims of more than $10,000), the panel comprises two public and one industry arbitrator. Because decisions are made by majority vote, this would seem to give the plaintiffs the edge. Moreover, plaintiffs and respondents can challenge any arbitrator. And each side has one peremptory challenge and unlimited challenges for cause. To be sure, the presumed expertise of the industry arbitrator could sway public arbitrators. This is the major complaint of those who want to get rid of industry arbitrators. A greater concern may be that industry lawyers may be more familiar with arbitration procedures than lawyers representing plaintiffs. But there is a simple solution for both perceived problems: Encourage public arbitrators and the plaintiff's bar to become more familiar with the securities industry, and its practices and rules. There is little evidence the current system is treating plaintiffs unfairly. The Securities Arbitration Commentator, a Maplewood, N.J., publication that has studied arbitration awards, found that 80% of claims settle in favor of the plaintiffs before a panel renders a judgment. Until recently, customers won awards in the majority of other cases. Last year's decline in the percentage of cases decided in favor of customers may well be because cases brought in the wake of the tech bubble collapse were weak. In the absence of significant evidence that the current system is shortchanging investors, let's not rush to make major repairs. Rather, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. of New York and Washington should work with NASAA of Washington and PIABA of Norman, Okla., on an in-depth, unbiased study of how well the current system is working. Some possible changes: require arbitrators to publish findings of fact, summarize how they reach their conclusions, and itemize components of any award they make. This would provide evidence of bias on either side and might eliminate that bias. The ultimate goal of the arbitration system must be that it is fair to both sides and that it is perceived as fair by both sides.

Latest News

SEC bars ex-broker who sold clients phony private equity fund
SEC bars ex-broker who sold clients phony private equity fund

Rajesh Markan earlier this year pleaded guilty to one count of criminal fraud related to his sale of fake investments to 10 clients totaling $2.9 million.

The key to attracting and retaining the next generation of advisors? Client-focused training
The key to attracting and retaining the next generation of advisors? Client-focused training

From building trust to steering through emotions and responding to client challenges, new advisors need human skills to shape the future of the advice industry.

Chuck Roberts, ex-star at Stifel, barred from the securities industry
Chuck Roberts, ex-star at Stifel, barred from the securities industry

"The outcome is correct, but it's disappointing that FINRA had ample opportunity to investigate the merits of clients' allegations in these claims, including the testimony in the three investor arbitrations with hearings," Jeff Erez, a plaintiff's attorney representing a large portion of the Stifel clients, said.

SEC to weigh ‘innovation exception’ tied to crypto, Atkins says
SEC to weigh ‘innovation exception’ tied to crypto, Atkins says

Chair also praised the passage of stablecoin legislation this week.

Brooklyn-based Maridea snaps up former LPL affiliate to expand in the Midwest
Brooklyn-based Maridea snaps up former LPL affiliate to expand in the Midwest

Maridea Wealth Management's deal in Chicago, Illinois is its first after securing a strategic investment in April.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.