Time for an assault on golden parachutes

It's time for all investors, institutional and individual, to tell boards of directors: "We're mad as hell, and we're not going to take it anymore!"
DEC 03, 2007
It's time for all investors, institutional and individual, to tell boards of directors: "We're mad as hell, and we're not going to take it anymore!" That is, investors must make boards understand they will no longer pay failed executives outrageous severance packages. And they must let the Securities and Exchange Commission hear it too. Unfortunately, the SEC last week voted down a proposed proxy-rules change that would have made it possible for shareholders to apply meaningful pressure on directors to hold them accountable. SEC Chairman Christopher Cox has promised to revisit the issue next year when new Democratic commissioners may make a change possible. It's evident that investors are weary of paying chief executives millions of dollars a year for mediocre (at best) performance and rewarding with multimillion-dollar severance packages those who fail and cost the companies and shareholders billions. While one board, that of Merrill Lynch & Co. Inc. in New York, seems to have received the message, many others may need two-by-fours across the forehead to get their attention. The Merrill Lynch board paid a high price in hiring John Thain as chief executive but tied most of the package to performance and promised no severance or pension benefits. His contract will pay him $750,000 a year, and he will receive 500,000 shares of restricted stock — worth, when he was hired, $28 million — and a bonus this year of $15 million. Mr. Thain also will receive 1.8 million Merrill Lynch options. Thus he will become even richer if he sorts out the company's problems, and shareholders will benefit too. But if Mr. Thain fails to lift Merrill Lynch out of the dumps, he will not prosper while the shareholders suffer. The Thain package is not perfect; his restricted stock and options will increase in value even if Merrill merely keeps pace with a rising market. Nevertheless, it is preferable by far to the packages paid to those who falter, such as Merrill Lynch's E. Stanley O'Neal and New York-based Citigroup Inc.'s Charles Prince. The failed executives may argue that large parts of their severance packages are deferred compensation — that is, money already earned. Shareholders can respond thus: "Since you have demolished the stock price, you haven't earned it. You should forfeit it." Mr. Thain's contract is a first model that should be improved upon by other boards. For example, incentive compensation should be tied not to stock performance on par with that of the market but to better-than-peer performance. Also, if earnings-per-share growth is used as a measure for an annual bonus, it must be adjusted for share buybacks, which are an easy way for CEOs to boost earnings per share. Investors also must hold boards accountable for ensuring that the CEOs are preparing their successors. Training a successor is a key responsibility that too many CEOs ignore. Hiring an outsider as CEO is evidence that the former CEO failed in their duty to train a successor. Studies show that outside successors cost far more than promoting from within. Perhaps board member compensation should also be tied to corporate performance — a proposal no board would adopt without significant outside pressure.

Latest News

Most retirees are now carrying credit card debt
Most retirees are now carrying credit card debt

Over half of people retiree sooner than expected, and rising costs due to inflation, along with unexpected expenses, are leading a growing proportion of retirees to turn to credit cards, EBRI found.

Corient, formerly CI Private Wealth, targets 2026 for IPO
Corient, formerly CI Private Wealth, targets 2026 for IPO

During the third quarter, Corient completed the acquisitions of two firms.

Trump's second term poses fresh risk to ESG investing
Trump's second term poses fresh risk to ESG investing

The president-elect's policies, mirroring the playbook he used eight years ago, creates challenges for the already declining space

Not all advisors on bitcoin bandwagon, despite record returns
Not all advisors on bitcoin bandwagon, despite record returns

Bitcoin may be hitting all-time highs, but that's not fazing some advisors who still view the cryptocurrency with skepticism.

Raymond James nabs more Edward Jones advisors in Washington
Raymond James nabs more Edward Jones advisors in Washington

The wealth management giant has bolstered its independent advisor arm again with the latest additions in the Pacific Northwest.

SPONSORED Out with the old and in with the new: a 50% private markets portfolio

A great man died recently, but this did not make headlines. In fact, it barely even made the news. Maybe it’s because many have already mourned the departure of his greatest legacy: the 60/40 portfolio.

SPONSORED Destiny Wealth Partners: RIA Team of the Year shares keys to success

Discover the award-winning strategies behind Destiny Wealth Partners' client-centric approach.