All-public Finra arb panels get big boost with SEC rule

'Claimants' lawyers will love it. Defense lawyers will hate it.'
OCT 10, 2013
Arbitration panels made up entirely of people without financial industry ties are likely to become the norm in customer cases against brokerage firms under a new rule. On Wednesday, the Securities and Exchange Commission approved a proposal by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. that would make an all-public panel the default option for choosing the three arbitrators deciding cases involving a claim of $100,000 or more. Previously, the plaintiff and defendant could select a process that guaranteed that at least one industry arbitrator would serve on their panel. Alternatively, one of the parties could require an all-public panel. Now the parties will have to opt out of an all-public panel. If they want to appoint an industry representative, they can do so by working with Finra staff. Since 2011, Finra has given customers filing cases against brokers the option of selecting all-public panels. They've done so 66% of the time over the past two years, according to Finra statistics. Those that used a public-industry panel usually did so by default because they didn't affirmatively select an all-public panel. The upward trend in using public arbitrators will accelerate under the new rule, according to experts. “Now there's absolutely no chance you're going to have an industry professional on your arbitration panel,” said Patrick Mahoney, owner of an eponymous law firm. “Claimants' lawyers will love it. Defense lawyers will hate it.” Removing the requirement that customers actively select all-public panels will help them and lawyers who are new to the Finra system. “The change will not affect those of us who regularly represent customers in cases, because we almost universally chose the [all-public] option anyway,” said Robert S. Banks Jr. of Banks Law Office PC. “It will benefit attorneys not experienced with Finra rules and investors who choose to represent themselves. The change recognizes that there are very few instances in which it is not to a customer's advantage to be able to decide whether to include an industry arbitrator.” The drawback of the new selection process is that it will diminish the role of industry arbitrators and the expertise they bring to the panels, according to S. Lawrence Polk, a partner at Sutherland Asbill & Brennan LLP. “In many cases, that industry arbitrator can be the harshest critic of the brokerage firm,” Mr. Polk said. “You're going to see an emphasis on expert witnesses.” Finra has a pool of approximately 6,000 arbitrators, about 4,000 of whom are public. With thousands of cases being filed each year, the system could be strained under the all-public approach, according to Mr. Polk. “It's going to be a real struggle to find enough public arbitrators to hear all these cases if we're eliminating the industry,” he said. Arbitration cases involving a registered representative against a firm will continue to be heard by two public arbitrators and one industry arbitrator.

Latest News

Maryland bars advisor over charging excessive fees to clients
Maryland bars advisor over charging excessive fees to clients

Blue Anchor Capital Management and Pickett also purchased “highly aggressive and volatile” securities, according to the order.

Wave of SEC appointments signals regulatory shift with implications for financial advisors
Wave of SEC appointments signals regulatory shift with implications for financial advisors

Reshuffle provides strong indication of where the regulator's priorities now lie.

US insurers want to take a larger slice of the retirement market through the RIA channel
US insurers want to take a larger slice of the retirement market through the RIA channel

Goldman Sachs Asset Management report reveals sharpened focus on annuities.

Why DA Davidson's wealth vice chairman still follows his dad's investment advice
Why DA Davidson's wealth vice chairman still follows his dad's investment advice

Ahead of Father's Day, InvestmentNews speaks with Andrew Crowell.

401(k) participants seek advice, but few turn to financial advisors
401(k) participants seek advice, but few turn to financial advisors

Cerulli research finds nearly two-thirds of active retirement plan participants are unadvised, opening a potential engagement opportunity.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today’s choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave