An intriguing idea: Let RIAs hire their own examiners

Regulators and RIAs would be better off if the latter were allowed to hire their own examiners — at least that's what one Georgetown professor contends.
JAN 30, 2012
It's an intriguing idea: Let RIAs hire their own examiners. That's the thinking offered in a study released yesterday by Georgetown professor James Angel. Neither the SEC or states have enough resources to examine advisers, and letting the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. take over would require passing controversial legislation, Mr. Angel said in an interview. So his idea is to let advisory firms outsource routine exams to accounting firms, consultants, SROs or even other advisory shops. Mr. Angel's study was sponsored by TD Ameritrade's RIA custody unit, so it's not going to be seen as a completely unbiased inquiry. But Mr. Angel, a frequent commenter on regulatory matters, could be opening another line of attack for advisers who want to avoid regulation by Finra. His paper essentially paints a fourth option to performing adviser exams, beyond the three options the SEC laid out in its own adviser-oversight study (have advisers pay user fees; set up an SRO; have Finra take on hybrids). Hiring outside auditors is the model corporate issuers follow, Mr. Angel argues, and the examination of a relatively small RIA shop is much simpler than poking into a public company. Most adviser exams are simply check-the-box routines, he said, as are Finra exams. "I think for a three-guy shop that doesn't custody accounts, having an examiner check in every three years is probably enough," Mr. Angel said. Outsourcing routine exams will free up SEC staff to do more important things, like for-cause examinations, Mr. Angel's study says. He said the SEC has all the power it needs to implement his plan. No more funding is needed (advisers would pay), and no controversial SRO bill would have to move through Congress. A key issue is what the qualifications should be for the firms and personnel that conduct the compliance reviews for advisers. Setting qualifications would be up to the SEC, Mr. Angel said. Mr. Angel's idea might sound good. Just keep in mind that it's bound to be opposed by the securities industry and Finra, who seem to be winning their share of political skirmishes in pushing for a self-regulatory organization for advisers. "The idea of having private accounting firms, hired by [advisers] evaluate sales practices raises a number of questions, including such firms' lack of experience and expertise in conducting sales practice evaluations," said Finra spokesman Howard Schloss in a statement. Finra believes supports having one or more SROs to take on adviser exams, he said. Mr. Angel's idea is a "non-starter," said Financial Services Institute Inc. spokesman Chris Paulitz, in an email. "Bernie Madoff was subject to the supervision of an auditing firm he handpicked and we all know how effective that turned out to be." The solution for adviser oversight "is a capable, competent regulator that is self-funded -- in short, Finra," Mr. Paulitz said. The goal of a uniform fiduciary standard for brokers and advisers is best done with " uniform examination, oversight, and enforcement," said Ira Hammerman, general counsel of the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, via email. "Using accounting or auditing firms to do the job simply would not offer the level of protection and oversight that retail investors deserve under a new uniform standard," he said.

Latest News

Roughly three-fifths of Americans agree on higher taxes for large corporations, higher-income households
Roughly three-fifths of Americans agree on higher taxes for large corporations, higher-income households

Pew survey reveals slight majority consensus on tax rates, but views splinter based on political alignment and income levels.

The Fed's going to cut rates
The Fed's going to cut rates

While the Federal Reserve's decision to hold interest rates steady in March was widely expected, it's the reactions from financial professionals that provide a more nuanced picture of the central bank's approach.

Ontario Pension Fund revamps PE business in light of global risk
Ontario Pension Fund revamps PE business in light of global risk

The pioneering member of Canada's Maple Eight is stepping back from its go-it-alone private equity approach as a drought in deals and Trump's trade war prompt a rethink.

Raymond James, RBC reel in UBS advisors managing over $690M in assets
Raymond James, RBC reel in UBS advisors managing over $690M in assets

The firms' latest additions in Florida and Nevada come as a strategic change at UBS raises risk of advisor defections.

Assetmark debuts new advisor succession planning program
Assetmark debuts new advisor succession planning program

The new program offers opportunities and events structured for rookies, next-gen advisor leaders, and soon-to-exit veterans.

SPONSORED Beyond the all-in-one: Why specialization is key in wealth tech

In an industry of broad solutions, firms like intelliflo prove 'you just need tools that play well together'

SPONSORED Record growth: Interval funds emerge as key players in alternative investments

Blue Vault Alts Summit highlights the role of liquidity-focused funds in reshaping advisor strategies