Another AI-washing case shows where SEC is headed

Another AI-washing case shows where SEC is headed
The Securities and Exchange Commission has focused on "black-and-white" allegations of AI washing, but that could broaden out to a gray area that may loop in more financial services companies, a lawyer says.
OCT 11, 2024

The SEC has brought another case against an investment advisor over alleged AI washing, on Thursday announcing charges against small California-based firm Rimar Capital and its owners.

That company is settling with the SEC for $310,000 in penalties, though it did not agree to admit or deny the SEC’s findings. Rimar and owners Itai Liptz and Clifford Boro allegedly made false or misleading statements about its purported use of AI around automated trading for clients while raising about $4 million among 45 investors, the SEC stated.

“Through entities he controlled, Liptz lured investors and clients with multiple fabrications, including with buzzwords about the latest AI technology,” said Andrew Dean, co-chief of the SEC’s asset management unit, in the announcement. “As AI becomes more popular in the investing space, we will continue to be vigilant and pursue those who lie about their firms’ technological capabilities and engage in ‘AI washing.'”

Additionally, the SEC found that the company and its owners “made misrepresentations about Rimar LLC’s assets under management and its investment returns … [and] obtained advisory clients using the misleading statements and that Liptz misappropriated company funds for personal expenses.”

The settlement includes a $250,000 civil penalty for Liptz and a $60,000 penalty for Boro. Liptz will also pay more than $213,000 in disgorgement and prejudgment interest and is barred from the industry for five years.

The SEC brought its first case concerning AI washing earlier this year, in March charging two companies: Delphia (USA) Inc. and Global Predictions, Inc., which settled the case for $400,000 in penalties. Then in June the regulator charged the owner and founder of a defunct AI recruitment startup, Joonko, alleging that the owner defrauded investors of $21 million by making false or misleading claims.

The SEC has also issued an investor alert focused on AI washing, and chair Gary Gensler has warned the financial services industry about it. In an Office Hours video posted last month, Gensler said that investment advisors and broker-dealers “should not mislead the public by saying they're using AI when they're not, nor say that they're using it in a particular way and not do so.” That could violate securities laws, he noted.

Although the handful of cases the SEC has filed so far appear to have been straightforward – a “layup” for the agency – it’s likely that enforcement will broaden out, said Dave Shargel, a partner at law firm Bracewell.

“There’s a good chance that enforcement actions will eventually move away from the black and white and into the gray areas, which raises questions about what does it mean to be using AI,” Shargel said. “There’s not singular definition of what AI is, and that can make it difficult for companies to describe it. And AI can be difficult to enforce.”

While many companies in different industries likely face risks around AI washing, the obvious way to address it is “don’t say you’re using AI when you’re just not,” Shargel said.

RIAs and broker-dealers should also be thoughtful in how they vet third-party AI providers whose services they plan to use, having a good understanding not only of what products are and can do but what they are not and cannot do, he said.

For context, observers should consider the enforcement the SEC has done around environmental, social, and governance claims – an area where the financial services industry has become extra careful when describing in public statements, he noted.

“This is just another indication that this [AI washing] is going to be part of the enforcement trend for the foreseeable future.”

Latest News

Investing for accountability: How to frame a values-driven conversation with clients
Investing for accountability: How to frame a values-driven conversation with clients

By listening for what truly matters and where clients want to make a difference, advisors can avoid politics and help build more personal strategies.

Advisor moves: Raymond James ends week with $1B Commonwealth recruitment streak
Advisor moves: Raymond James ends week with $1B Commonwealth recruitment streak

JPMorgan and RBC have also welcomed ex-UBS advisors in Texas, while Steward Partners and SpirePoint make new additions in the Sun Belt.

Cook Lawyer says fraud claims are Trump’s ‘weapon of choice’
Cook Lawyer says fraud claims are Trump’s ‘weapon of choice’

Counsel representing Lisa Cook argued the president's pattern of publicly blasting the Fed calls the foundation for her firing into question.

SEC orders Vanguard, Empower to pay more than $25M over failures linked to advisor compensation
SEC orders Vanguard, Empower to pay more than $25M over failures linked to advisor compensation

The two firms violated the Advisers Act and Reg BI by making misleading statements and failing to disclose conflicts to retail and retirement plan investors, according to the regulator.

RIA moves: Wells Fargo pair joins &Partners in Virginia
RIA moves: Wells Fargo pair joins &Partners in Virginia

Elsewhere, two breakaway teams from Morgan Stanley and Merrill unite to form a $2 billion RIA, while a Texas-based independent merges with a Bay Area advisory practice.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.