Disclosures in SEC advice rule confuse, mislead investors, advocacy groups say

Disclosures in SEC advice rule confuse, mislead investors, advocacy groups say
Testing by Financial Planning Coalition, Consumer Federation of America and AARP uncovers problems.
SEP 12, 2018

Disclosures contained in the Securities and Exchange Commission's investment advice reform proposal meant to clarify the differences between investment advisers and brokers confuse and mislead investors, several advocacy groups said Wednesday. The organizations conducted independent investor testing of the so-called client relationship summary, or Form CRS, in the reform package. The disclosure is designed to illuminate for investors the varying services, compensation models and standards of care that each kind of financial professional offers. In a letter to SEC chairman Jay Clayton, the groups said they found that investors did not comprehend differences in services, legal obligations, fees and costs, and conflicts of interest despite using Form CRS. "In area after area tested, participants didn't just fail to fully grasp the information provided — time and again they walked away with a false understanding of the issues," Barbara Roper, director of investor protection at the Consumer Federation of America, told reporters on a conference call. "If the disclosures fail, the entire regulatory approach fails." In addition to the CFA, the Financial Planning Coalition and AARP sponsored the testing, which was conducted by Kleimann Communications. The coalition is comprised of the Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards Inc., the Financial Planning Association and the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors. The testing involved 90-minute, one-on-one interviews with a total of 16 investors with a variety of educational and income levels in Calabasas, Calif., Philadelphia and St. Louis. The SEC introduced its reform package in April, and the comment period ended Aug. 7. The advocacy groups indicated in comment letters they would conduct the testing. On Wednesday, they encouraged the agency to use their results to inform its own efforts to assess disclosure effectiveness. It's not clear what kind of testing the SEC is doing or whether the agency will allow for another public comment period before completing advice reform. "If they rush the rule proposal through ahead of knowing whether it works, that would be a real abuse of process," Ms. Roper said. “The SEC welcomes all feedback on its proposed Form CRS that will help us make decisions about ways to improve disclosure for investors,” an SEC spokesperson said in a statement. “The SEC is currently engaged in investor testing. As chairman Clayton indicated in his public statement on April 24, we anticipate making the results of that investor testing available in the public comment file.” The SEC has held a series of investor roundtables over the last couple of months. In each of them, agency staff has provided participants with copies of Form CRS and then discussed their reaction to it. That's not the same as investor testing, according to Ms. Roper. "It doesn't tell you whether the disclosures work," she said. "It doesn't tell you whether when they read these documents, they come away able to make a better decision" on whom to hire.

Latest News

Investing for accountability: How to frame a values-driven conversation with clients
Investing for accountability: How to frame a values-driven conversation with clients

By listening for what truly matters and where clients want to make a difference, advisors can avoid politics and help build more personal strategies.

Advisor moves: Raymond James ends week with $1B Commonwealth recruitment streak
Advisor moves: Raymond James ends week with $1B Commonwealth recruitment streak

JPMorgan and RBC have also welcomed ex-UBS advisors in Texas, while Steward Partners and SpirePoint make new additions in the Sun Belt.

Cook Lawyer says fraud claims are Trump’s ‘weapon of choice’
Cook Lawyer says fraud claims are Trump’s ‘weapon of choice’

Counsel representing Lisa Cook argued the president's pattern of publicly blasting the Fed calls the foundation for her firing into question.

SEC orders Vanguard, Empower to pay more than $25M over failures linked to advisor compensation
SEC orders Vanguard, Empower to pay more than $25M over failures linked to advisor compensation

The two firms violated the Advisers Act and Reg BI by making misleading statements and failing to disclose conflicts to retail and retirement plan investors, according to the regulator.

RIA moves: Wells Fargo pair joins &Partners in Virginia
RIA moves: Wells Fargo pair joins &Partners in Virginia

Elsewhere, two breakaway teams from Morgan Stanley and Merrill unite to form a $2 billion RIA, while a Texas-based independent merges with a Bay Area advisory practice.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.