Finra engages in rulemaking by enforcement: financial industry groups

FSI and SIFMA criticize broker-dealer regulator for creating standards based on settlements.
JUN 21, 2017

Financial industry trade associations criticized Finra for using enforcement to establish regulatory standards for brokers rather than the formal rulemaking process, in letters to the broker-dealer regulator as part of its self-examination process. The Financial Services Institute, which represents independent brokers and financial advisers, said that as the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. has increased its fine level, FSI members are wondering about the broker-dealer self-regulator's motivation. "Recent developments in fines have lead [sic] members to believe that enforcement has moved away from investor protection and is now actively creating standards and rules outside the rulemaking process," David Bellaire, FSI executive vice president and general counsel, wrote in a June 19 comment letter. "Furthermore, some FSI members report that they feel the threat of large fines is being used to force them to sign [settlements]. The drastic rise in fines combined with lower restitution rates tend to show that Finra is using the enforcement mechanism to regulate members rather than make investors whole." The FSI based its comment in part on a study by Brian L. Rubin and Adam C. Pollet of the law firm Eversheds Sutherland that shows that Finra fines reached a record $176 million in 2016, an increase from $94 million in 2015, while investor restitution decreased to $28 million in 2016 from $96 million in 2015. The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association made a similar assertion, saying that its members were targets of enforcement actions based on "unofficial legal positions taken by Finra staff," such as when a settlement becomes an "interpretation...applied to all firms," or when decisions are based on remarks in a Finra official's speech. "Member firms find 'regulation by enforcement' extremely troublesome because it creates legal standards and imposes retroactive regulatory requirements and legal liability outside the formal rulemaking process," SIFMA president and chief executive Kenneth E. Bentsen Jr. wrote in a May 8 comment letter. "Earlier this spring, FINRA President and CEO Robert W. Cook asked the public to provide their thoughts and ideas on improvements to FINRA's current engagement programs," Finra spokeswoman Nancy Condon said in a statement. "We thank those who have commented for their thoughtful feedback, which we will consider in our evaluation to help ensure FINRA is the most effective and efficient regulator it can be." The FSI and SIFMA were responding to a 30-page March 21 request for comment in which Finra asked for feedback about its engagement with member firms. The solicitation of comments is part of the Finra 360 initiative launched by Mr. Cook in which the organization is reviewing its operations. The comment deadline was June 19. The expansive request for comment provided an opportunity for respondents to evaluate a range of Finra activities, policies and structure. For instance, the Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association criticized the makeup of the Finra committees and its board of governors, where it said it wanted to see more investor advocates. The Finra board is comprised of 23 members, 12 of whom are "public governors" and 10 of whom are "industry governors." Mr. Cook also sits on the board. "While the Finra Board of Governors has its purported 'public' governors, it would appear from their background and/or current positions that most of them are not what PIABA would consider to be investor advocates," PIABA president Marnie Lambert wrote in a June 19 comment letter. She cited five public governors who are currently or were formerly associated with investment firms or have ties to the financial industry.

Latest News

Five-person Raymond James team jumps to Janney in Maryland
Five-person Raymond James team jumps to Janney in Maryland

The group led by a 37-year industry veteran brings $470 million in assets to the Philadelphia-based broker dealer.

$20B Merit looks to next phase as Constellation takes minority stake
$20B Merit looks to next phase as Constellation takes minority stake

The Atlanta, Georgia-based national wealth firm revealed its new PE partner as prior backers Wealth Partners Capital Group and HGGC’s Aspire Holdings exited their investments.

$350M father-son duo hops from Osaic to Equitable Advisors
$350M father-son duo hops from Osaic to Equitable Advisors

The latest departures in Ohio mark another setback for the hybrid RIA, which is looking to "expanding its presence across all models and segments of the wealth management industry.”

Fresh off HPS acquisition, BlackRock inks deal for $7.3B ElmTree Funds
Fresh off HPS acquisition, BlackRock inks deal for $7.3B ElmTree Funds

The St. Louis-based real estate investment firm gives the asset management giant a valuable access point to the roughly $1 trillion net lease market.

SEC charges Chicago-based investment adviser with overbilling clients more than $2.5M in fees
SEC charges Chicago-based investment adviser with overbilling clients more than $2.5M in fees

Eliseo Prisno, a former Merrill advisor, allegedly collected unapproved fees from Filipino clients by secretly accessing their accounts at two separate brokerages.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.