Finra rogue broker proposal raises concerns among investor, industry advocates

Finra rogue broker proposal raises concerns among investor, industry advocates
PIABA: It falls short of solving unpaid arbitration. FSI: It gives Finra too much power.
JUL 08, 2019

Investor advocates say a Finra proposal to crack down on rogue brokerages doesn't go far enough to solve the problem of unpaid arbitration awards, while industry groups are expressing concerns that it gives Finra too much power to determine violations. Under a rule proposed in May, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. would impose tougher oversight of broker-dealers with a track record of violations or that hire a high number of registered representatives with disciplinary histories. If Finra designates a firm as "restricted," it could be required to make deposits into accounts managed by Finra that would be used in part to pay arbitration awards. The rule gives firms ways to avoid the designation, including reducing the number of rogue brokers on its staff. In a July 1 comment letter, the Public Investors Arbitration Bar Association said Finra should acknowledge the proposal is "an incremental step toward protecting investors from high-risk firms." But the group said it falls short of tackling the ongoing problem of broker-dealers shirking their responsibility to pay arbitration awards. "We have seen no data that shows the sums set aside will be sufficient to cover anticipated arbitration awards," wrote PIABA president Christine Lazaro and vice president Samuel B. Edwards. State securities regulators criticized the proposal for not addressing how or if customer complaints removed from a registered representative's record will be used to determine which firms require additional financial obligations. "Not counting the number of expungements in the preliminary identification criteria could also lead to firms encouraging — or even facilitating — expungements for their associated persons in the hopes of avoiding designation as a restricted firm," wrote Michael Pieciak, Vermont financial regulation commissioner and president of the North American Securities Administrators Association Inc. in a July 1 comment letter. Finra has indicated that about 61 of the approximately 3,700 broker-dealers it regulates would be targeted under the proposed rule. The Financial Services Institute, which represents independent broker-dealers and financial advisers, worries that Finra would wield too much power. "FSI believes that the proposed rule would benefit from clear parameters around the discretion that will be exercised by Finra and clarification on the impact to net capital requirements and small firms," wrote Robin Traxler, FSI senior vice president for policy and deputy general counsel, in a July 1 comment letter. The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association praised the Finra proposal for putting the burden of setting aside cash on firms with disciplinary histories, but the group added that the firms should be involved in the designation process. "Firms should have the in-house ability to make the same exact calculation as Finra to determine if the firm meets the preliminary criteria for identification," wrote Kevin Carroll, SIFMA managing director and associate general counsel, in a July 1 comment letter. "This would allow a firm to monitor itself on a continuous basis, self-police and address any issues before Finra comes knocking on its door." The comment deadline was July 1. Finra could modify the proposal before releasing a final rule, which would then have to be approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Latest News

Trump loses patience as SALT block stymies GOP tax bill
Trump loses patience as SALT block stymies GOP tax bill

The president urged Republicans repping high-tax states including New York to accept a $30,000 deduction cap for now, but the holdouts remain dug in.

'Disgruntled' ex-Wells Fargo advisor loses fight with firm over loan money
'Disgruntled' ex-Wells Fargo advisor loses fight with firm over loan money

An effort by the advisor to move to the bank's independent contractor division proved to be a critical detail to the dispute.

Ex-Osaic advisor fined over failure to declare $1M bequest
Ex-Osaic advisor fined over failure to declare $1M bequest

The New York-based advisor, formerly affiliated with Securities America, has also been suspended for failing to disclose his status as a beneficiary.

Are advisors missing retirees' needs in 'fragile decade'?
Are advisors missing retirees' needs in 'fragile decade'?

Survey suggests financial professionals are falling behind investors' need for guaranteed income and asset protection in their golden years.

RIA acquirer Bluespring welcomes Georgia-based Clarivise Private Wealth
RIA acquirer Bluespring welcomes Georgia-based Clarivise Private Wealth

The Alpharetta-based advisor ensemble enters a new chapter in its partnership with the Kestra Financial subsidiary.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave

SPONSORED The evolution of private credit

From direct lending to asset-based finance to commercial real estate debt.