FSI presses SEC to end ‘regulation by enforcement’

FSI presses SEC to end ‘regulation by enforcement’
FSI says regulator must start giving accused fair notice that behavior is out of compliance.
JAN 30, 2024

The Financial Services Institute released a plan Tuesday that it says will enable the SEC to avoid penalizing financial firms and advisors for violating federal securities laws when the alleged perpetrators don’t know they’ve done anything illegal.

For many years, FSI and other industry trade associations have accused the Securities and Exchange Commission of so-called regulation by enforcement. That occurs, they say, when the SEC takes an enforcement action without giving fair notice that the behavior it's targeting is out of compliance with the agency’s rules.

For instance, financial industry critics of the SEC’s ongoing crackdown over inadequate disclosure of mutual fund fees say the regulator didn't explain that long-time industry practices in the area were violations. The SEC has maintained that advisors are violating their fiduciary duty to clients when they fail to tell them they are recommending high-price share classes when less expensive ones are available in the same fund.

In a white paper released Tuesday, FSI outlined policies and procedures the SEC should adopt to prevent regulation by enforcement. Before any “first of its kind enforcement action,” the SEC should consider whether there has been “reasonable and fair notice to both the subject of the enforcement action and to other potentially affected parties” through rules, guidance, public statements and reports, the paper states.

The white paper also recommends that the SEC obtain feedback from potentially affected firms and their representatives, such as trade groups, regarding the effect of the policy spurring the enforcement action. The agency also should consider alternatives to enforcement, such as rulemaking or risk alerts. The SEC has received the white paper, FSI said.

“We believe these changes should be uncontroversial and consistent with policy interests of the commission,” Robin Traxler, FSI senior vice president and deputy general counsel, told reporters during the organization’s OneVoice conference in Orlando, Florida. “In our democracy, no one should be subject to government agency enforcement action without prior fair notice of the standards, rules or laws that form the basis of the alleged violation.”

An SEC spokesperson declined to comment on FSI’s recommendations. She pointed to a speech given last fall by SEC Chair Gary Gensler in which he addressed major enforcement actions, such as the agency’s crackdown on record-keeping violations involving financial firms’ use of off-channel communications.

“Some may call high-impact cases regulation by enforcement,” Gensler told the Securities Enforcement Forum in October. “I call it enforcing the laws and the regulations that are on the books.”

Several years ago, Steve Peikin, then the co-director of the SEC’s Division of Enforcement, said he didn’t understand industry criticism of the share-class-selection enforcement initiative. Failure to disclose 12b-1 and other mutual fund fees is a clear violation of fiduciary duty, he said at a 2019 conference. Most of the violations occurred in advisory accounts of clients at dually registered financial firms.

But an FSI official said the organization’s members, who are independent broker-dealers and financial advisors, were blindsided by the share-class initiative because they were disclosing fund fees.

“They used language which was standard industry practice and had been for years,” said David Bellaire, FSI executive vice president and general counsel.

Pushing back on what it thinks is regulation by enforcement is one of FSI’s policy priorities this year. Another is opposing a Department of Labor rule on independent contractors that the group believes threatens the advisory business model of its members. FSI also is pushing DOL to withdraw an investment advice proposal that it says imposes too costly a regulatory burden.

Will M&A in the RIA industry stay hot in 2024?

Latest News

SEC Says Game Service Roblox Part of ‘Active Investigation’
SEC Says Game Service Roblox Part of ‘Active Investigation’

Short sellers previously said the company was under investigation, though Roblox denied allegations.

Musk’s DOGE descends on CFPB with intention to shut it down
Musk’s DOGE descends on CFPB with intention to shut it down

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is in the crosshairs of the Republican group that is widely attempting to dismantle government agencies.

Advisor fighting Finra banishment loses $17.7 million dispute with old firm
Advisor fighting Finra banishment loses $17.7 million dispute with old firm

National Securities Corp. sued the advisor in 2020, alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment.

Job numbers, inflation leaving room for Fed to hold rates
Job numbers, inflation leaving room for Fed to hold rates

Recent data support a measured pace by the Federal Reserve for the year ahead.

Private assets remain hot despite surging stock market
Private assets remain hot despite surging stock market

Financial advisors are still adding alternatives despite the surge in publicly traded stock prices

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.