Leading state regulator sees arbitration reform gaining momentum

Leading state regulator sees arbitration reform gaining momentum
A NASAA model rule gives states the ability to yank the license of a brokerage or advisory firm that dodges an arbitration award or other judgment.
JUN 06, 2022

A leading state securities regulator is confident that arbitration reform will gain momentum at the state level.

The North American Securities Administrators Association, which is made up of securities regulators from all 50 states as well as Canada, Mexico and other jurisdictions, recently approved a model arbitration rule that would make it a dishonest or unethical practice for a broker or investment adviser not to pay an investment-related arbitration award to a customer.

The measure also sanctions the failure to pay a judgment, fine, civil penalty, restitution, disgorgement or similar penalty imposed by a state regulator, the Securities and Exchange Commission or the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc.

Now that the NASAA membership has passed the model rule, NASAA President Melanie Senter Lubin expects individual states will begin taking it up, either through a legislative or regulatory process, depending on the state.

“This to me is the kind of rule where I would expect to see a lot of states move to adopt it,’ said Lubin, who is also Maryland’s securities commissioner.

The reason is that the model gives states another way to attack an ongoing problem — unpaid arbitration awards. It raises the stakes by allowing state regulators to yank the license of a brokerage or advisory firm that dodges such payments.   

“A firm that wants to stay in business will have an additional incentive to pay judgments and awards because otherwise their license is at risk,” Lubin said.

Finra, the broker-dealer self-regulator, has the power to bar from the industry brokerages and registered representatives who don’t pay arbitration awards. Finra has been under pressure for years to solve the problem, which is getting worse, according to a recent study by the Public Investors Advocate Bar Association.

If states adopt the NASAA rule, it not only can address the problem when it occurs at brokerages but also would provide a means for targeting investment advisers who fail to pay arbitration awards, said Christine Lazaro, a professor of law at St. John’s University.

Investor advocates assert that advisers’ use of mandatory arbitration is more opaque and costly than the arbitration forum that Finra runs to adjudicate disputes between customers and reps and brokerages.

The NASAA model rule “is a good step, especially in the [adviser] space, to create accountability for arbitration awards to make sure they get paid,” said Lazaro, director of the St. John’s Securities Arbitration Clinic. “It will give the states something else to look at on the advisory side so that we don’t just have the bad actors shifting from one space [brokerage] to the other [adviser].”

The NASAA model rule received mixed reactions when it was open for public comment last fall.

“The goal of this rule is to help investors collect unpaid judgments and awards,” Lubin said. “This is a clean, direct way to get there.”

The extent to which the model rule will solve the problem will be determined over the next several months as state legislatures and regulatory agencies consider it.

“It’s going to depend on how many states adopt it,” Lazaro said.  

Latest News

CFP Board floats new procedural rules around bankruptcy, misdemeanors
CFP Board floats new procedural rules around bankruptcy, misdemeanors

If approved, the proposed revisions would achieve outcomes similar to the existing process while reducing the burden of oversight.

What pre-retirees don't know about Social Security could be hurting them, says T. Rowe Price
What pre-retirees don't know about Social Security could be hurting them, says T. Rowe Price

Survey research reveals gaps in retirement savers' knowledge, pessimism around receiving benefits, and a lack of good options to solve looming solvency crisis.

Could active ETFs act as a client acquisition magnet?
Could active ETFs act as a client acquisition magnet?

Actively managed ETFs may offer an edge for advisors courting Gen X, millennial, and Gen Z investors, according to Capital Group.

Vanguard connected with Blackstone, Carlyle on potential private market tie-ups
Vanguard connected with Blackstone, Carlyle on potential private market tie-ups

The exploratory talks, reported by unnamed sources, speak to a larger trend of traditional asset managers wading further into the alternative assets space.

CEO rails against DEI rollbacks
CEO rails against DEI rollbacks

Claims of merit miss the point, according Stoy Hall.

SPONSORED Retirement plan balances are flourishing. Why are so many advisors missing out on a $3 trillion opportunity?

Participants who receive professional 401(k) advice see higher returns on average, net, than those who don't.

SPONSORED Focus on clients, not compliance – why Gary Corderman found his fit with Farther

This wealth management platform finally delivers on the technology promises other firms couldn't - giving advisors a better way to scale and serve