New Jersey brokers expect industry will push back against fiduciary rule proposal

New Jersey brokers expect industry will push back against fiduciary rule proposal
Brokerage executives expect the industry to put up a fight against the rule, which they say will lead to a complex web of compliance.
SEP 27, 2018

New Jersey brokerage executives expressed consternation over adding another layer of regulation by requiring them to adhere to a fiduciary standard, predicting officials will face stiff headwinds in getting it across the finish line. "The state of New Jersey is taking on a tall order in trying to do this," said Michael Karalewich, CEO of Nationwide Planning Associates Inc., an independent broker-dealer based in Paramus, N.J. "Their heart is in the right place," Mr. Karalewich added. "But there's definitely going to be pushback from the industry. We watched what happened with the DOL [fiduciary rule]. I would expect we'd see some of that here for firms operating in New Jersey." New Jersey governor Phil Murphy announced Sept. 17 that the state's Bureau of Securities would be issuing a proposal to set a fiduciary standard governing investment advice provided by broker-dealers and their representatives. The proposal is in response to the death of the Department of Labor's fiduciary rule, which was overturned in court, and the Securities and Exchange Commission's own investment-advice proposal, which isn't yet final but which the governor feels will "fall short." "They have the [legal] right to do it, I think, but I don't know if it's a smart thing to do," said Damon Testaverde, chairman of Network 1 Financial Securities Inc., a hybrid practice based in Red Bank, N.J. "We need to have efficient capital markets." "We just have to be careful of what we propose and how we propose it," Mr. Testaverde said. While specific details of the proposal are still hazy, the governor has said the rule would create a uniform fiduciary standard for brokers and registered investment advisers. Executives said an additional tier of rules from another entity — the state — would be tough. And New Jersey may be just the tip of the iceberg; experts believe other states could follow suit. Only six other states have more brokerage firms than New Jersey, which has 472, according to the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. "You have costs at the SEC level with regulation, at the Finra level, at the state level. And if there's no consistency, that's where it becomes challenging for advisers, broker-dealers, clients and attorneys," said Thomas Hyland, president of TFS Securities Inc., based in Middletown, N.J. "Having to answer to three masters and duplicate efforts in improving compliance becomes very challenging," Mr. Hyland said. "If the lines of regulation are drawn as straight, dark, black lines, it would be easy." Mr. Hyland, whose firm has about 200 advisers and $4 billion in assets, said he is in favor of a fiduciary standard, but that he would prefer a single level of oversight to simplify compliance and supervision. More regulation in the state, he said, may cause smaller firms and advisers to "reconsider their position in the business" and whether "they have the resources, time and money to comply." "It doesn't mean I have to leave New Jersey, but I won't be calling customers in New Jersey," said Mr. Testaverde of Network 1 Financial Securities. "I'll be calling customers in other states." Mr. Karalewich of Nationwide Planning Associates, which has around 125 registered representatives and $2.5 billion in assets under management, said the brokerage industry would prefer the SEC to take the lead on governing investment advice. At the same time, Mr. Karalewich acknowledged that he'd be supportive of New Jersey's regulatory change because it "is what's ultimately best for the investing public." Further, preparing to comply with the DOL fiduciary rule, which raised investment advice standards in retirement accounts before getting quashed earlier this year, could potentially make compliance with a state fiduciary rule easier, he said. "It'd be hard not to get behind the concept," Mr. Karalewich said. "It's not going to cause me to change the way that we operate. If the rule is something we have to abide by, then we'll embrace it.

Latest News

FINRA suspends Centaurus broker who piled clients into REITS, BDCs
FINRA suspends Centaurus broker who piled clients into REITS, BDCs

Most firms place a limit on advisors’ sales of alternative investments to clients in the neighborhood of 10% a customer’s net worth.

Advisor moves: LPL Financial, Osaic, Raymond James all welcome new teams
Advisor moves: LPL Financial, Osaic, Raymond James all welcome new teams

Those jumping ship include women advisors and breakaways.

Mariner announces an acquisition double, adding $1.7B to its AUA
Mariner announces an acquisition double, adding $1.7B to its AUA

Firms in New York and Arizona are the latest additions to the mega-RIA.

Michigan insurance agent to stand trial after charges of insurance fraud
Michigan insurance agent to stand trial after charges of insurance fraud

The agent, Todd Bernstein, 67, has been charged with four counts of insurance fraud linked to allegedly switching clients from one set of annuities to another.

NY Appeals court tosses $500M civil fraud penalty against Trump; upholds injunctive relief
NY Appeals court tosses $500M civil fraud penalty against Trump; upholds injunctive relief

“While harm certainly occurred, it was not the cataclysmic harm that can justify a nearly half billion-dollar award to the State,” Justice Peter Moulton wrote, while Trump will face limits in his ability to do business in New York.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.