Opponents of DOL fiduciary rule want SEC to modify suitability standard

ICI chief executive Paul Schott Stevens is the latest to telegraph the route the financial industry wants the agency to take.
MAY 08, 2017

Some suspense surrounds the fate of the Department of Labor fiduciary rule. Among the cliffhangers: Will new Labor Secretary Alexander Acosta extend the delay of the regulation's implementation date beyond June 9? What part of the rule will be modified as a result of the reassessment called for by President Donald J. Trump? Or will it be repealed altogether? If it is repealed, will the Securities and Exchange Commission step into the void and propose its own uniform fiduciary rule for retail investment advice? Here's a question that's not so suspenseful: What kind of new fiduciary standard is on the wish list of industry opponents of the DOL rule? Spoiler alert: They don't want one. They want a modification of the suitability standard that governs brokers' sales of investment products, and they want it to focus on disclosure. The Investment Company Institute, which represents the mutual fund industry, is the latest trade association to state the direction in which it wants the advice debate to go. "We are calling upon the SEC to propose a harmonized best-interest standard for broker-dealers that would enhance, rather than replace, existing suitability obligations," ICI president and chief executive Paul Schott Stevens said at the organization's general membership meeting last week. The ICI's defense of the suitability standard, which requires brokers to sell investment products that suit a client's risk tolerance, time horizon and other factors, resembles the approach the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association is advocating. SIFMA, another major trade association for financial firms, has proposed its own best-interest standard. What SIFMA did is essentially update the suitability standard. The recent statement by Mr. Stevens and the outline provided by SIFMA draws the battle lines for a possible SEC attempt to write its own fiduciary rule, should the DOL measure be substantially changed or eliminated. Proponents will say — in fact, have said — that the industry is proposing a fiduciary standard "in name only." Tweaking the suitability standard doesn't make it a true best-interest standard like the one that investment advisers must now meet. Backers of the DOL rule say it is the closest regulators have come to establishing a fiduciary standard. In fact, a participant on an ICI panel following Mr. Stevens' speech wondered why so many in the industry are resisting the DOL regulation's requirement that financial advisers act in the best interest of their clients in retirement accounts. "It strains credulity to say, 'Let's not have a rule that forces us to do that,'" Eli Broverman, co-founder of Betterment, said at the ICI event. He was responding to another industry official who joined him on the ICI panel, Ben Huneke, managing director and head of investment solutions at Morgan Stanley Wealth Management. Mr. Huneke said he supports a best-interest standard for advice, but that the DOL rule "has a lot of unfortunate consequences practically." "The high-level direction is good for the industry, and we embrace it," Mr. Huneke said. Sorting out what that means won't be easy. "The devil's in the details," said Skip Schweiss, managing director of adviser advocacy and industry affairs at TD Ameritrade Institutional, in an interview. "What does a harmonized best-interest standard look like?" The industry wants a best-interest standard but also wants suitability to be its foundation. That's fodder for a many-years war, if not a 100 Years War.

Latest News

RIA moves: True North adds $353M California RIA as SageView grows North Carolina presence
RIA moves: True North adds $353M California RIA as SageView grows North Carolina presence

Plus, a $400 million Commonwealth team departs to launch an independent family-run RIA in the East Bay area.

Top Commonwealth advisor to recruiters: Stop with the cold calls already!
Top Commonwealth advisor to recruiters: Stop with the cold calls already!

“I respectfully request that all recruiters for other BDs discontinue their efforts to contact me," writes Thomas Bartholomew.

Blue Owl Capital, Voya strike private market partnership for retirement plans
Blue Owl Capital, Voya strike private market partnership for retirement plans

The collaboration will focus initially on strategies within collective investment trusts in DC plans, with plans to expand to other retirement-focused private investment solutions.

Why AI notetakers alone can't fix 'broken' advisor meetings
Why AI notetakers alone can't fix 'broken' advisor meetings

Wealth tech veteran Aaron Klein speaks out against the "misery" of client meetings, why advisors' communication skills don't always help, and AI's potential to make bad meetings "100 times better."

Morgan Stanley, Goldman, Wells Fargo to settle Archegos trades lawsuit
Morgan Stanley, Goldman, Wells Fargo to settle Archegos trades lawsuit

The proposed $120 million settlement would close the book on a legal challenge alleging the Wall Street banks failed to disclose crucial conflicts of interest to investors.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.