Robert Cook says Finra doesn't levy fines to balance budget

Robert Cook says Finra doesn't levy fines to balance budget
Regulator's CEO says the agency has "extra cash in the till," referring to excess reserves to fill any shortfall.
MAR 25, 2019

Finra chief executive Robert Cook told industry compliance officials Monday the regulator does not levy fines in order to balance its budget. "Fines are not collected for budget purposes," Mr. Cook said at a Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association conference in Phoenix. "We don't have a target for fines. That's the key." Last week, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. released its budget summary for 2019. The regulator anticipates that operating expenses will exceed operating revenues by about $76 million, and that the shortfall may require Finra to draw about $186 million from its reserves. By relying on reserves to fill the budget gap, Finra will be able to avoid a membership fee increase for the sixth year in a row. The term "reserves" is sort of informal in Finra nomenclature. It's the equivalent of the regulator's investment portfolio, which is approximately $1.7 billion. Finra's goal is to maintain reserves at a level above annual expenses, which in 2019 are projected to be about $1 billion. That gives Finra an approximately $700 billion pool to tap to cover a shortfalls. "We have extra cash in the till, so to speak," Mr. Cook said in the SIFMA session. Finra sets its budget assuming fines are zero. The actual fine level can vary widely from year to year. In 2016, Finra levied a record $173.8 million. In 2017, the number dropped to $64.9 million. In a SIFMA panel following Mr. Cook's session, Finra executive vice president and head of enforcement Susan Schroeder said fines are not an end in themselves, but are a way to send compliance messages. "We think of fines as a way to tell that story," she said. In an interview, Mr. Cook acknowledged concerns about whether Finra is trying to hit a certain level of fines each year. That's why the organization emphasizes that its budget doesn't depend on such revenue. "I appreciate the question, and it's something we're trying to address through greater transparency and clarity in our thinking," he said. In the next few weeks, Finra is expected to release its second annual accounting of how it spends fine money. EXAM REFORM, 529 INITIATIVE Mr. Cook also addressed examination reform, telling the SIFMA audience that Finra is trying to ensure at least a six-month break for firms between examinations. In addition, he reiterated that Finra launched its self-reporting initiative on 529 college savings plan sales because it was noticing a lack of supervision surrounding the transactions. Brokerages were not taking the appropriate steps to determine what kind of 529 would be best for a client based on the client's objectives. "It wasn't necessarily about what particular share class was being recommended," Mr. Cook said. "It was more about whether the supervision was happening at all."

Latest News

FINRA suspends Centaurus broker who piled clients into REITS, BDCs
FINRA suspends Centaurus broker who piled clients into REITS, BDCs

Most firms place a limit on advisors’ sales of alternative investments to clients in the neighborhood of 10% a customer’s net worth.

Advisor moves: LPL Financial, Osaic, Raymond James all welcome new teams
Advisor moves: LPL Financial, Osaic, Raymond James all welcome new teams

Those jumping ship include women advisors and breakaways.

Mariner announces an acquisition double, adding $1.7B to its AUA
Mariner announces an acquisition double, adding $1.7B to its AUA

Firms in New York and Arizona are the latest additions to the mega-RIA.

Michigan insurance agent to stand trial after charges of insurance fraud
Michigan insurance agent to stand trial after charges of insurance fraud

The agent, Todd Bernstein, 67, has been charged with four counts of insurance fraud linked to allegedly switching clients from one set of annuities to another.

NY Appeals court tosses $500M civil fraud penalty against Trump; upholds injunctive relief
NY Appeals court tosses $500M civil fraud penalty against Trump; upholds injunctive relief

“While harm certainly occurred, it was not the cataclysmic harm that can justify a nearly half billion-dollar award to the State,” Justice Peter Moulton wrote, while Trump will face limits in his ability to do business in New York.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.