SEC reveals general outlines of how it decides where to try enforcement cases

SEC reveals general outlines of how it decides where to try enforcement cases
But guidance on using in-house judges versus federal court falls short, lawyers say.
JUN 08, 2015
The Securities and Exchange Commission Division of Enforcement released guidance last Friday that outlines how it selects venues for trying enforcement claims. But the explanation of how it decides to bring cases before in-house judges rather than try them in federal court falls short of making the process more transparent and fair, lawyers said Monday. Among the factors considered are the nature of the case, forms of relief sought and how quickly the case can be decided. The guidance, which runs a little more than three pages, also said certain investment adviser and broker actions can only be tried in front of the SEC's own administrative law judges. “The division recommends the forum that will best utilize the commission's limited resources to carry out its mission,” the guidance states. “There is no rigid formula dictating the choice of forum.” SEC Chairwoman Mary Jo White told a Senate Appropriations subcommittee last Tuesday the agency was considering releasing public guidelines that would make the administrative process “clear and transparent for both the parties and public.” Critics have said the in-house procedures give the SEC a home-court advantage in enforcement cases. A Wall Street Journal study published last Wednesday found that the SEC won 90% of the cases it brought through administrative proceedings from October 2010 through March 2015. Richard Marshall, a partner at Ropes & Gray, said the biggest concern about the administrative process is whether it's fair to defendants. “The guidance is fairly vague,” Mr. Marshall said. “I don't think that the standard fully addresses the fairness point. There's still a substantial element of discretion that these guidelines give staff.” The guidelines don't detail whether the agency has to prove in the administrative venue that a defendant is likely to commit violations again, a standard that must be met in federal court, said Dennis Stubblefield, a partner at Shustak & Partners. In the administrative arena, a finding that the enforcement is in the public interest is sufficient, he said. “I'm disappointed,” said Mr. Stubblefield, a former SEC branch chief enforcement officer in Miami. “They have more work to do. They're just issuing factors [in the guidance]. They're not addressing the core process by which they might make the administrative process more fair and transparent.” Thomas Gorman, a partner at Dorsey and Whitney, agrees that the guidelines do little to clear up doubts about the administrative process. “While it clearly would be beneficial if the SEC addressed the questions regarding forum selection to reassure the public regarding the fairness of its processes, this memorandum misses the mark,” Mr. Gorman wrote in his blog. “It offers virtually no insight into what can only be viewed as a 'black box' process used by the agency to make these critical decisions.” An SEC representative could not be reached for comment.

Latest News

The fight over the CFPB is just beginning
The fight over the CFPB is just beginning

Locked out of their offices and told to stay home, employees at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau have asked the courts to intervene as Elon Musk and Republican leaders move to shut down the agency that was established to protect people from predatory lending and financial scams.

Business-focused wealth tech RISR lands $8B Wealthcare Capital Management partnership
Business-focused wealth tech RISR lands $8B Wealthcare Capital Management partnership

Fintech platform interVal has also introduced a new feature to help advisors support entrepreneurial business owner clients better.

LPL boosts revenue potential with amped-up alts platform
LPL boosts revenue potential with amped-up alts platform

Along with greater revenue, alternative investments also carry risks, one industry lawyer noted.

How SageSpring Wealth Partners' next-gen strategy has fueled its success
How SageSpring Wealth Partners' next-gen strategy has fueled its success

President Jeff Dobyns unpacks the strategic power of mentorship, what makes an "ideal team player," and how the firm's 89 percent success rate has paid off for veteran advisors.

Powell heads for hot-seat hearings with ongoing pressure from Trump policies
Powell heads for hot-seat hearings with ongoing pressure from Trump policies

The Fed chair is in for some "hyper-charged" meetings, with legislators likely to raise questions on tariff threats and apparent steps to comply with anti-DEI orders.

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.