SIFMA, Finra clash over deadbeat brokers

Increasingly, brokerages are being stiffed by ex-reps who were given hefty loans as recruiting incentives. SIFMA wants Finra to write a tougher rule to help battle deadbeat brokers. So far, no dice.
MAR 20, 2012
The Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association wants Finra to crack down on deadbeat brokers who have failed to pay back promissory notes. Specifically, the trade group wants the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. to change its rules so that brokers can't plead poverty to get out of an arbitration repayment order. The upshot is that there could be more suspensions and more bankruptcies if brokers can't pay back promissory notes. The notes are used to provide cash for recruiting and retention incentives, and are structured as forgivable loans as long as brokers stay at the firm for an agreed-upon period. If they leave early, they are supposed to pay back the note. Many brokers got the deals after the financial crisis, which prompted broker movement and firm mergers. Meanwhile, firms have gotten increasingly aggressive in filing arbitration claims for repayment, and they generally win, observers said. Last year, 778 promissory note cases were filed, following an even bigger surge of 1,152 cases in 2010, according to Finra. If brokers refuse to pay an arbitration award, Finra brings a separate action against them that can result in suspension from the industry. But if a broker can show an inability to pay back a note, he or she can avoid suspension and still go to work at another firm. That is aggravating to SIFMA members, many of whom said that they have been stiffed by former employees. “This is money firms gave in good faith to these brokers, so I'm not sure why regulators wouldn't facilitate” payment of awards, said Kevin Carroll, SIFMA associate general counsel. SIFMA wants Finra to eliminate the inability-to-pay defense for industry cases, just as it did in 2010 for unpaid awards involving customers. In these cases, if brokers can't pay, they must file for bankruptcy or else face suspension. SIFMA made its case to Finra in November in a six-page letter and in subsequent meetings. It argued that allowing deadbeat brokers to work in the industry, especially without disclosure of their financial predicament, puts customers at risk. But Finra doesn't seem persuaded by SIFMA's arguments. Mr. Carroll acknowledged that if Finra agrees, it could look as though it was serving as the industry's debt collector. Finra spokeswoman Michelle Ong declined to comment. SIFMA may raise the issue with the Securities and Exchange Commission. “We expect within weeks to decide what our next course of action will be,” Mr. Carroll said.

COLLECTION IS COSTLY

Firms can pursue normal collection efforts to get paid back, but that's expensive and often fruitless. “There's a lot of cost ... and in a collection proceeding, you might get 10% or 20% [of brokers] to pay up,” said D. Daxton White, founder of  The White Law Group LLC, who's defended numerous brokers in note cases. “Firms would rather just put a guy out of business,” he added. SIFMA also has been pushing for better disclosure of unpaid awards. “We think brokers would think twice about raising that defense if they knew it would become public,” Mr. Carroll said. Even some on the other side of these broker disputes see SIFMA's point. The rule covering the inability-to-pay defense “should apply across the board and make no exception for industry awards,” said David Robbins, a partner at Kaufmann Gildin Robbins & Oppenheim LLP, who handles both customer and broker defense cases. Not so, said Patrick Burns of the Law Offices of Patrick J. Burns Jr. PC, who represents brokers. Customer cases present “a different issue altogether” than industry cases, he said. “It undermines confidence if customer claims are not being paid.” And as for firms, “perhaps they should take more care with the unsecured loans [they're] giving out,” he added. [email protected]

Latest News

Citigroup continues strategic investment banking talent raid on JPMorgan
Citigroup continues strategic investment banking talent raid on JPMorgan

Since Vis Raghavan took over the reins last year, several have jumped ship.

Slow is smooth, smooth is fast
Slow is smooth, smooth is fast

Chasing productivity is one thing, but when you're cutting corners, missing details, and making mistakes, it's time to take a step back.

Edward Jones layoffs about to hit employees, home office staff
Edward Jones layoffs about to hit employees, home office staff

It is not clear how many employees will be affected, but none of the private partnership's 20,000 financial advisors will see their jobs at risk.

CFP Board hails record July exam turnout with 3,214 test-takers
CFP Board hails record July exam turnout with 3,214 test-takers

The historic summer sitting saw a roughly two-thirds pass rate, with most CFP hopefuls falling in the under-40 age group.

Founder of water vending machine company, portfolio manager, charged in $275M Ponzi scheme
Founder of water vending machine company, portfolio manager, charged in $275M Ponzi scheme

"The greed and deception of this Ponzi scheme has resulted in the same way they have throughout history," said Daniel Brubaker, U.S. Postal Inspection Service inspector in charge.

SPONSORED Delivering family office services critical to advisor success

Stan Gregor, Chairman & CEO of Summit Financial Holdings, explores how RIAs can meet growing demand for family office-style services among mass affluent clients through tax-first planning, technology, and collaboration—positioning firms for long-term success

SPONSORED Passing on more than wealth: why purpose should be part of every estate plan

Chris Vizzi, Co-Founder & Partner of South Coast Investment Advisors, LLC, shares how 2025 estate tax changes—$13.99M per person—offer more than tax savings. Learn how to pass on purpose, values, and vision to unite generations and give wealth lasting meaning