Supreme Court backs SEC, rules against investment banker

Supreme Court backs SEC, rules against investment banker
Banker held liable for taking part in scheme to defraud investors.
MAR 27, 2019
By  Bloomberg

The U.S. Supreme Court reinforced the Securities and Exchange Commission's powers, upholding sanctions against an investment banker found to have duped investors about a startup company's financial condition. The justices, voting 6-2, said Francis V. Lorenzo, who worked at Charles Vista, could be held liable for taking part in a scheme to defraud investors even if he didn't write two deceptive emails at the center of the case. (More:Financial literacy: An epic fail in America) The ruling, which upholds a federal appeals court, halts a trend of Supreme Court rulings that had trimmed the SEC's authority. The decision also bolsters the rights of private investors, giving them more power to press lawsuits claiming deception. "Congress intended to root out all manner of fraud in the securities industry," Justice Stephen Breyer wrote for the majority. "And it gave to the commission the tools to accomplish that job." Justices Clarence Thomas and Neil Gorsuch dissented. Writing for the two, Mr. Thomas said that Mr. Lorenzo "might have assisted in a scheme, but he did not himself plan, scheme, design or strategize." Such a person still could be held liable for aiding and abetting, Mr. Thomas wrote. Justice Brett Kavanaugh didn't take part in the case because he had participated in it as an appeals court judge. (More:SEC orders new enforcement hearings as a result of Supreme Court ruling) Mr. Lorenzo contended he couldn't be held liable because he had merely forwarded deceptive emails written by his boss. The emails misrepresented the financial health of a client, Waste2Energy Holdings Inc., which was failing in its efforts to develop a way to generate electricity from solid waste. An in-house SEC judge said the emails were "staggering" in their falsity.

Latest News

Schwab bumps up fee for RIAs using its referral service
Schwab bumps up fee for RIAs using its referral service

Schwab's referral program has not changed its fees in almost 20 years.

Trump demands lower interest rates as Powell goes to Hill
Trump demands lower interest rates as Powell goes to Hill

The president's call for monetary policy easing marks a shift from earlier remarks calling the Fed's January hold "the right thing to do."

Advisors react to Trump 2.0
Advisors react to Trump 2.0

The president may be the same as he was before, but circumstances are different this time around – and there are some lessons from the first term, advisors said.

The war on DEI
The war on DEI

Financial services companies are being targeted for potential legal action over their programs and initiatives on diversity, equity, and inclusion. It could be just the beginning.

Advisors weigh reputational risks, regulatory shifts in digital asset adoption
Advisors weigh reputational risks, regulatory shifts in digital asset adoption

Client sentiment and the regulatory climate may be getting sunnier, but fiduciary concerns are still holding three-fifths of surveyed advisors back from embracing crypto investments.

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.