Supreme Court questions SEC’s power to recoup billions

Supreme Court questions SEC’s power to recoup billions
The justices considered the commission's use of “disgorgement” to collect ill-gotten gains from wrongdoers
MAR 04, 2020
By  Bloomberg
Supreme Court justices appeared ready to limit the Securities and Exchange Commission’s ability to recoup ill-gotten profits from wrongdoers, hearing arguments on a legal tool the commission has used to collect billions of dollars. In an hour-long session Tuesday, the justices considered the SEC’s use of “disgorgement” to collect money from someone the commission sues in federal court. Disgorgement is distinct from fines and other penalties the SEC seeks, in part because it’s geared toward reimbursing victims. The justices didn’t appear willing to altogether eliminate disgorgement, which opponents say the SEC is using as an illegal punishment. The argument suggested the court instead might bar the commission from collecting more than the amount of profit a defendant gained through fraud. The justices also indicated they might require the agency to return more money to harmed investors. Justice Sonia Sotomayor focused on the SEC’s practice of sending much of the money it collects to the treasury. “If the treasury is getting it, we don’t really know if it’s being used to help investors,” she said. Without the disputed power, the SEC wouldn’t have been able to use federal courts to obtain about $1.5 billion in disgorgement orders last year, said Urska Velikonja, a professor at Georgetown University Law Center who tracks the agency’s enforcement data. President Donald J. Trump’s administration and the SEC are defending the power, saying it comes from federal courts’ inherent authority and three statutes passed by Congress, including the 2002 Sarbanes-Oxley Act. Protecting investors The Sarbanes-Oxley law doesn’t explicitly mention disgorgement but says judges hearing SEC enforcement actions can award “any equitable relief” they deem appropriate to protect investors. Courts have traditionally viewed disgorgement as an “equitable” measure, which means judges make awards based on fairness rather than strict legal rules. The justices are hearing an appeal by Charles Liu and Xin Wang, a California couple fighting a $27 million disgorgement order. They were found to have defrauded people seeking to take advantage of a visa program for foreigners who make large U.S. investments. Mr. Liu and Ms. Wang were accused of falsely telling investors their money would be used for a cancer treatment center. The couple’s attorneys say the order in their case went well beyond the $8 million the trial judge found they had gained from their scheme. They point to a 2017 Supreme Court decision that said disgorgement is covered by a five-year statute of limitations that applies to penalties. But on Tuesday, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg questioned whether the 2017 decision dictated the outcome of the latest case. The ruling declined to say whether the SEC has the power to seek disgorgement in the first place. “It was not saying that in every context it is a penalty,” Ms. Ginsburg said. [More: SEC tallies more enforcement activity in 2019, increases penalties, money returned to investors]

Latest News

Five-person Raymond James team jumps to Janney in Maryland
Five-person Raymond James team jumps to Janney in Maryland

The group led by a 37-year industry veteran brings $470 million in assets to the Philadelphia-based broker dealer.

$20B Merit looks to next phase as Constellation takes minority stake
$20B Merit looks to next phase as Constellation takes minority stake

The Atlanta, Georgia-based national wealth firm revealed its new PE partner as prior backers Wealth Partners Capital Group and HGGC’s Aspire Holdings exited their investments.

$350M father-son duo hops from Osaic to Equitable Advisors
$350M father-son duo hops from Osaic to Equitable Advisors

The latest departures in Ohio mark another setback for the hybrid RIA, which is looking to "expanding its presence across all models and segments of the wealth management industry.”

Fresh off HPS acquisition, BlackRock inks deal for $7.3B ElmTree Funds
Fresh off HPS acquisition, BlackRock inks deal for $7.3B ElmTree Funds

The St. Louis-based real estate investment firm gives the asset management giant a valuable access point to the roughly $1 trillion net lease market.

SEC charges Chicago-based investment adviser with overbilling clients more than $2.5M in fees
SEC charges Chicago-based investment adviser with overbilling clients more than $2.5M in fees

Eliseo Prisno, a former Merrill advisor, allegedly collected unapproved fees from Filipino clients by secretly accessing their accounts at two separate brokerages.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.