Supreme Court to consider challenge to SEC disgorgement powers

Supreme Court to consider challenge to SEC disgorgement powers
California couple fighting a $27 million disgorgement order argue the agency lacks the power to demand the penalty.
NOV 01, 2019
By  Bloomberg
The Supreme Court agreed to consider stripping the Securities and Exchange Commission of its power to recoup illegal profits from wrongdoers, taking up a challenge to one of the agency's most potent legal weapons. The appeal by Charles Liu and Xin Wang contends that "disgorgement" isn't one of the remedies Congress has authorized the SEC to seek against people who violate the nation's securities fraud laws. The California couple is fighting a $27 million disgorgement order. The SEC won disgorgement orders totaling $2.5 billion in fiscal 2018, compared with $1.4 billion in other types of penalties. [Recommended video: Social Security COLA not great news for 2020, says Mary Beth Franklin]​ Disgorgement is designed to return ill-gotten gains to people who were harmed. Courts have traditionally viewed it as an "equitable" measure, which means judges make awards based on fairness rather than strict legal rules. The 2002 Sarbanes-Oxley Act says judges hearing SEC enforcement actions can award "any equitable relief" they deem appropriate for the protection of investors. [More: Is SEC disgorgement endangered? Supreme Court to decide]

'Huge sums'

But Mr. Liu and Ms. Wang's attorneys say the SEC has sought so much money through disgorgement that it's become a punitive measure, much like a penalty. "The SEC collects huge sums of money by pursuing a penalty that it does not have the power to seek in federal court," the appeal argued. Mr. Liu and Ms. Wang point to a 2017 Supreme Court decision that said disgorgement is covered by a five-year statute of limitations that applies to penalties. That ruling explicitly declined to say whether the SEC has power to seek disgorgement in the first place. The Trump administration and the SEC urged the Supreme Court to reject the appeal, saying Congress authorized the commission to seek disgorgement in three separate statutes. The administration told the justices the Supreme Court "has repeatedly characterized disgorgement as an equitable remedy." Mr. Liu and Ms. Wang were found to have defrauded people seeking to take advantage of a visa program for foreigners who make large investments in the U.S. The two were accused of falsely telling investors the money would be used for a cancer treatment center. A federal judge ordered the couple to return $27 million they collected. The case is Liu v. SEC, 18-1501. [More: RIA takes dispute with Fidelity to the Supreme Court]

Latest News

Is the SEC's private fund exemption rule about to change?
Is the SEC's private fund exemption rule about to change?

House bill seeks inflation-based adjustment to private fund adviser exemption.

Congress pushes to make fintech oversight offices permanent at SEC, CFTC
Congress pushes to make fintech oversight offices permanent at SEC, CFTC

A new House measure would enshrine FinHub and LabCFTC as permanent fixtures, deepening ties with financial technology sector.

CFP Board names Barry Gersten head technology officer
CFP Board names Barry Gersten head technology officer

The seasoned IT leader arrives as the credentialing body for CFP professionals considers AI's implications for the future of financial planning.

FINRA and advisors' other work
FINRA and advisors' other work

The brokerage industry regulator once again takes a stab at updating rules for independent brokers with other businesses and jobs

Minority capital comes with caution
Minority capital comes with caution

Transactions have slowed according to recent data as industry insider warns that the trip doesn't always match the brochure when minority investors come onboard.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today’s choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave