The DOL fiduciary rule: Deal catalyst or deal killer?

Industry conversation is now turning to the regulation's impact on M&A activity.
OCT 20, 2016
As the wealth management industry slowly comes to terms with the pending implementation of the Department of Labor's best-interest rule, the industry conversation is now turning to the impact the rule will have on M&A activity. According to Echelon Partners' research and analysis, approximately $3.1 trillion of client assets representing $18.5 billion in revenue will be impacted at national and regional independent and full-service brokerage firms, bank broker-dealers, insurance broker-dealers and dually registered firms. The prohibited transaction revenue from these segments is estimated to be approximately 10% to 14% of current revenues, or roughly $2 billion to $2.5 billion. (More: In the wake of the DOL fiduciary rule, will adviser M&A surge?) While discount brokerages, robo-advisers and independent RIAs likely will benefit from this rule, the older, incumbent brokerage firms will be hurt in five ways: • Elimination of revenues from disallowed products • Movement to lower-revenue products within the universe of allowed products • Increased expenses to educate staff, modify processes and upgrade technology • Increased costs for insurance and supervision • Higher penalties for non-compliance Given the already thin margins in the broker-dealer industry, these changes can potentially become a matter of life or death for these firms, spurring on the question of whether or not M&A activity will spike or decline. Will there be consolidation, or will these impacted businesses appear undesirable, resulting in a dearth of buyers? Those thinking that deal making will cool as a result of the DOL rule point to the fact that there are very real risks involved in acquiring broker-dealer businesses, given their declining economics and valuations in a post-DOL world. Further, incumbent firms will tend to soldier on rather than want to sell at the bottom, as they are in it for the long run. They will focus on migrating to new business models over time and attempting to manage their way out of their predicament. (More: Already sizzling market for advisory firms could be stoked by DOL fiduciary rule) On the other hand, there could be a significant opportunity for savvy buyers to pick up these firms on the cheap, with lots of upside. Many of the risks inherent to acquiring these firms can be managed through smart deal structuring. Additionally, by engineering an impacted firm's business model away from commissions and toward fees, a very large increase in valuation can be achieved in a relatively short period of time. Thus, there could be a swarm of large, resource-rich companies looking to gain scale and grow. These resource-rich firms could be supported by a plethora of service firms offering products, technology and other systems readily available to deploy to manage compliance risks, further encouraging legacy firms to become sellers to enhance their competitive positioning. In the meantime, market signals are indicating that there is dramatic change coming, one way or the other. Various recent adviser surveys show that anywhere from 10% to 25% of advisers are planning on exiting the business over the next few years in response to the DOL rule, which heightens the question of whether they will shut down or sell. On the other hand, there have been some very high-profile deals, such as the recent acquisition of AIG's Advisor Group unit by Lightyear Capital, in which the buyers specifically cited the DOL rule as the reason driving the acquisition. As a result, the impact of the DOL rule remains uncertain just six short months prior to the deadline to comply. Dan Seivert is CEO of Echelon Partners, a leading investment bank and consulting firm serving the wealth management industry.

Latest News

In an AI world, investors still look for the human touch
In an AI world, investors still look for the human touch

AI is no replacement for trusted financial advisors, but it can meaningfully enhance their capabilities as well as the systems they rely on.

This viral motivational speaker can also be your Prudential financial advisor
This viral motivational speaker can also be your Prudential financial advisor

Prudential's Jordan Toma is no "Finfluencer," but he is a registered financial advisor with four million social media followers and a message of overcoming personal struggles that's reached kids in 150 school across the US.

Fintech bytes: GReminders and Advisor CRM announce AI-related updates
Fintech bytes: GReminders and Advisor CRM announce AI-related updates

GReminders is deepening its integration partnership with a national wealth firm, while Advisor CRM touts a free new meeting tool for RIAs.

SEC charges barred ex-Merrill broker behind Bain Capital private equity fraud
SEC charges barred ex-Merrill broker behind Bain Capital private equity fraud

The Texas-based former advisor reportedly bilked clients out of millions of dollars, keeping them in the dark with doctored statements and a fake email domain.

Trump's tax bill passes senate in hard-fought victory for Republicans
Trump's tax bill passes senate in hard-fought victory for Republicans

The $3.3 trillion tax and spending cut package narrowly got through the upper house, with JD Vance casting the deciding vote to overrule three GOP holdouts.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.