Finra arbitrators order Raymond James, rep to pay nearly $20 million in raiding case

Finra arbitrators order Raymond James, rep to pay nearly $20 million in raiding case
Wells Fargo alleged that a 'coordinated' effort to lure away advisors depleted an Arkansas branch office, forcing it to close.
FEB 02, 2023

Finra arbitrators ordered Raymond James and a financial advisor affiliated with the firm to pay nearly $20 million to Wells Fargo Advisors for depleting an Arkansas branch office of its reps.

Wells Fargo alleged that Raymond James Financial Services Inc. and six financial advisors conducted a “coordinated raid” of the Wells office in Mountain Home, Arkansas. In the statement of claim, Wells said the branch was forced to close.

A unanimous panel of three Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. arbitrators held Raymond James and Kent Jackson Rhoades jointly liable and ordered them to pay $15,300,000 in compensatory damages, according to a Feb. 2 award. Rhoades also must pay Wells $3,500,000 in attorneys’ fees and $847,000 in costs.

Rhoades left Wells Fargo’s Mountain Home office in October 2018 to establish Financial Services & Investment Strategies Group in the same town. Rhoades’ new firm is part of Raymond James’ independent channel.

Wells Fargo accused Raymond James, Rhoades and five other advisors — Steven Bettenhausen, David Matty, Janet Schmeski, Michael Stockton and Logan Stone — of unfair competition, breach of contract and illegal interference in its business, among other causes of action.

Rhoades and the other advisors denied the allegations, according to the award document. In a counterclaim, Rhoades, Bettenhausen, Matty, Schmeski and Stone alleged that after they left Wells Fargo, the firm assigned their clients to replacement advisors who then convinced their former clients to sever their relationships with them “through untruths and/or deception.”

Grappling over who “owns” clients when advisors move from firm to firm makes up some of the fiercest arbitration and court battles in the financial industry. Wells Fargo and Raymond James squared off under similar circumstances in 2010.

Wells Fargo was happy to win again this time.

“Wells Fargo Advisors is pleased with the outcome and appreciates the arbitration panel’s recognition of the damages caused by this conduct,” Wells Fargo spokesperson Jackie Knolhoff said in a statement.

Raymond James declined to comment. Rhoades did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

PIABA targets unpaid arbitration awards, ‘punitive’ RIA arb clauses

Latest News

GLP-1 users are trading retirement savings for their prescriptions
GLP-1 users are trading retirement savings for their prescriptions

A Nationwide survey finds 47% of GLP-1 users have never discussed the drugs’ financial impact with an advisor, even as many dip into savings.

Inspired Healthcare sale price of properties is 59% of $1.2 billion sold by advisors
Inspired Healthcare sale price of properties is 59% of $1.2 billion sold by advisors

The hundreds of millions of dollars from a sale of Inspired Healthcare properties does not mean an immediate windfall for investors.

Class action alleges Webull misled investors about China operations
Class action alleges Webull misled investors about China operations

Its SEC filings said one thing - a congressional probe said another.

Investors accuse Netcapital of inflating revenue through sham deals
Investors accuse Netcapital of inflating revenue through sham deals

Sham agreements allegedly padded revenue by 345%.

Pre-retirees are looking for flexibility, security, and guidance when it comes to retirement income: Cerulli
Pre-retirees are looking for flexibility, security, and guidance when it comes to retirement income: Cerulli

"Most pre-retirees are uncomfortable making key retirement income decisions without an advisor's help," said Chris Bailey of Cerulli.

SPONSORED Built on insurance experience to deliver on long-term promises

Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.

SPONSORED In the Age of AI, Trust Becomes the Advisor's Greatest Asset

As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor