Labor Secretary nominee Alexander Acosta says little about DOL fiduciary rule

During confirmation hearing, he talks mostly about overtime and minimum wage issues, although he's noncommital about his positions on those matters.
MAR 22, 2017

President Donald J. Trump's nominee for labor secretary expressed support for increasing the salary threshold at which overtime must be paid to employees, but declined to commit to defend the rate put in place by the Obama administration. During Alexander Acosta's confirmation hearing before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee Wednesday, Chairman Lamar Alexander, a Tennessee Republican, criticized the Obama administration's move to extend overtime benefits to millions more workers and pressed Acosta on his views. Mr. Acosta said it was unfortunate that such a threshold could go unchanged for over a decade, but that doubling the limit as Obama attempted "does create what I'll call a stress on the system." Senators from both parties sought to pin Acosta down on how we would handle the rule, without great success. Acosta told South Carolina Republican Tim Scott that he understood the senators' desire to know what he would do, but "this is an incredibly complicated rule," he said. "What I would say is I understand the extreme economic impact that a doubling has in certain parts of the economy," Mr. Acosta said. "Because of the size of the increase there are serious questions as to whether the secretary of Labor even has the power to enact this in the first place." That did not seem to satisfy Mr. Scott, who told the nominee, "These are things that you should be contemplating already." Overtime Impact Asked about the issue by Sen. Patty Murray of Washington, the committee's ranking Democrat, Mr. Acosta said, "the overtime rule hasn't been updated since 2004. We now see an update that is a very large revision, and something that needs to be considered is the impact it has on the economy, on nonprofits, on geographic areas that have lower wages. But I'm also very sensitive to the fact that it hasn't been updated since 2004." In a fiery exchange, Massachusetts Democrat Elizabeth Warren pressed Mr. Acosta repeatedly, and unsuccessfully, to commit to leave in place the rule enacted under Mr. Obama making standards more stringent for exposure to cancer-causing silica dust. Mr. Acosta told her "I cannot make a commitment" because the White House has ordered review of regulations. Ms. Warren expressed belief to Mr. Acosta that "you want to be secretary of labor but you have no opinion" on the issue. Ms. Warren also criticized Mr. Acosta's unwillingness to say whether he would defend the overtime rule in court, saying, "You've had time to take a look at it and it's not a long ruling." Budget Cut Mr. Acosta avoided making commitments when asked by several senators about the fate of particular programs or agencies under Mr. Trump's proposed 21% cut in the department's funding. Asked by New Hampshire Democrat Maggie Hassan about potential cuts to health and safety inspectors' ranks, he answered, "Can I commit to no less than current levels? That's a very precise statement and something is going to have to give somewhere in the budget." He added, "I think that worker safety is incredibly important." Trump tapped Mr. Acosta Feb. 16 to replace his first nominee, CKE Restaurants Inc. CEO Andrew Puzder, who withdrew amid controversies, including his past employment of an undocumented housekeeper, a domestic-abuse accusation in his divorce proceedings and alleged labor law violations at CKE's Hardee's and Carl's Jr. brands. Mr. Acosta arrives with much less personal controversy. He's also been less outspoken than Mr. Puzder, a frequent media commentator, about Labor Department issues like the fate of Mr. Obama's rule making millions more employees eligible for overtime, which a Texas judge has blocked. During his opening statement, Mr. Acosta touted his "paycheck to paycheck" upbringing, and he promised to fairly enforce the law as senators pressed him on overtime rules and political pressure on hiring. "As a former prosecutor, my enforcement efforts will always be on the side of the law," Mr. Acosta said. Two Republican senators and former presidential candidates, Marco Rubio and Ted Cruz, introduced Mr. Acosta to the committee prior to his opening statement. "He has a sterling record of public service to our state and country," Mr. Rubio told his colleagues, adding that he has "continuously demonstrated his ability to effectively tackle the problems at hand with ease." Mr. Cruz praised him as "a man of character" and "a man who has a passion for justice," saying he has "an impeccable record" in each of his part public service jobs. Citing Obama labor regulations in areas like overtime and financial adviser conflicts of interest, Mr. Alexander said they had created "a big, wet blanket of costs" for business. Mr. Alexander praised Mr. Acosta as a nominee "who understands how a good-paying job is critical to helping workers realize the American dream for themselves and for their families." Mr. Acosta, the Florida International University law school dean, described for senators how his parents fled Cuba in search of freedom, then worked as a typist and inventory clerk to support him. "They were able to give me these opportunities they did not have because though they didn't have a college education, they had something very important — and that's a job,"he said. Mr. Acosta, in his opening statement, emphasized his concern about the so-called "skills gap" between workers' skills and employers' needs; his commitment to enforce workplace safety laws; and his intent to be an "advocate for the American workforce" within the Trump administration. He cites the support his nomination has drawn from some unions familiar with his past government work. "They know that while we did not always agree, I was always willing to listen and to consider and to seek principled solutions," he said. Bush Appointments Before taking the law school job, Mr. Acosta was appointed by George W. Bush and confirmed by the Senate for three past positions: member of the National Labor Relations Board, head of the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division, and U.S. attorney. "There are a lot of blank spots in the Trump administration's agenda about incredibly important issues that make a huge difference to working families," said Portia Wu, a former assistant secretary at the Labor Department under Mr. Obama. "And we really need to know what they're planning. So this hearing is an important opportunity to try to get some answers to those questions." Labor groups, who helped defeat Mr. Puzder, have been far more conciliatory toward his replacement. AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka last month told Fox Business Network he likes Mr. Acosta "much more" than Puzder, and "he deserves absolute serious consideration." A few unions, including the Laborers International Union of North America and the International Association of Fire Fighters, have already endorsed Mr. Acosta's nomination.

Latest News

Orion, RFG moves take aim at onboarding and transition speed
Orion, RFG moves take aim at onboarding and transition speed

Orion and RFG Advisory tackle account-opening delays with new updates as custodial integrations reshape how fast advisors can move client assets.

Corient adds $5B New York multi-family office Seven Bridges
Corient adds $5B New York multi-family office Seven Bridges

The deal extends the acquisitive mega-RIA's rapid 2026 expansion as industry consolidation hits record levels nationwide

Navigating the straight
Navigating the straight

As recent Middle East tensions put the Strait of Hormuz back in focus, a structured process with purpose can help protect investors against their natural self-sabotaging tendencies in choppy markets.

Commonwealth-affiliated Longwave hires from LPL-affiliated firm amid Pacific Northwest expansion
Commonwealth-affiliated Longwave hires from LPL-affiliated firm amid Pacific Northwest expansion

ESG-focused Longwave Financial, approaching $1B AUM, acquired Seattle-based MG Financial and hired a client services manager from an LPL-affiliated firm.

Securitize becomes RIA as tokenized assets near $37B record
Securitize becomes RIA as tokenized assets near $37B record

Tokenization goes mainstream with regulators watching prompting some firms to take a proactive approach.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income