Extreme market volatility caused by concerns about the coronavirus is likely to cause an outbreak in Finra arbitration cases, two experts predicted in a recent blog post.
The market gyrations inevitably will generate claims by investors against their brokers as they question whether financial professionals had their backs as their accounts fell precipitously.
In their blog post, What’s Past is Prologue, George Friedman, editor-in-chief of the Securities Arbitration Alert, and Rick Ryder, founder and president of the Securities Arbitration Commentator, wrote that the effect of past market disruptions on arbitration illustrate what’s likely to happen this time around.
They point to the “Black Monday” crash in October 1987, the “Tech Wreck” in 2000 and the financial crisis in 2008-09 as examples of severe market downturns that led to an increase in arbitration claims.
“When the markets perform well, arbitration filings decline,” Mr. Friedman and Mr. Ryder wrote. “When there are prolonged significant market declines, the case filings surge as surely as the swallows return to Capistrano. Simply put, people fight less when they are making money, and they fight more when they are losing money.”
The market endured a 7.5% plunge on Monday, its worst since the financial crisis. Early Tuesday afternoon, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was up about 100 points.
“The market volatility enhances the prospect of even more arbitration cases than a pure down market,” said Mr. Friedman, a former director of arbitration at the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc.
It may take a while for the arbitration traffic to tick up. The number of Finra arbitration cases peaked at 8,945 three years following the tech disruption in the early 2000s. Cases then declined until the financial crisis, spiking again to 7,137 in 2009.
During the prolonged bull market, which was stampeding until the coronavirus hit, Finra arbitration cases dropped significantly. Last year, there were 3,757 cases filed, down from 4,325 in 2018.
The kinds of cases that could start percolating include those centering on suitability, execution, overconcentration, margin and employment, Mr. Friedman and Mr. Ryder wrote. An execution case, for example, could be based on the failure of an online broker like Robinhood to maintain trading capability during market chaos.
The spread of the coronavirus could force a change in Finra arbitration operations, Mr. Friedman said. There may be a reluctance to have the parties in a case gather in a physical location for a hearing.
“It’s going to cast a new light on online arbitration and video conferencing,” he said.
On Monday, Finra released guidance for brokerage firms on business continuity plans. The self-regulator didn’t mention any adjustments to arbitration procedures.
As the coronavirus continues to spread, the market is not likely to calm down. That increases Mr. Friedman’s confidence that his and Mr. Ryder’s projections about arbitration cases will come true.
“I’m more convinced now, given the volatility,” he said.
Mara Glassel and Julie Fox will co-lead the fast-growing hybrid RIA’s ultra-high-net-worth and private wealth businesses.
The banking giant's wealth arm extends its revenue streak as it pushes to exit consent orders weighing on growth since 2020.
New Allspring research finds 401(k) participants want guidance on income and rollovers, not just portfolio automation.
Aging homeowners hold record housing wealth - but most advisors still aren't bringing it into retirement plans
$1.7M invested from an inheritance. Then the phone went dead.
Knighthead Life entered the market with a competitive MYGA. A strong launch earned advisor confidence and paved the way for FIAs.
As AI makes financial information more accessible than ever, Lana Hock explains why human judgment, trust, and empathy remain the qualities clients value most in a financial advisor
