401(k) lawsuits keep coming, despite COVID-19

401(k) lawsuits keep coming, despite COVID-19
Two lawsuits over plans’ target-date investments were filed in the past week, and there was a major development in another case
MAR 19, 2020

The COVID-19 scare has led to an unprecedented amount of remote working arrangements, and the court system is no exception, at least when it comes to ERISA.

The pace of 401(k) litigation does not yet appear to be slowing. In the past week, Wells Fargo was sued over the use of proprietary funds in its retirement plan. A case was also filed against BOK Financial, and there was a major development this week in a lawsuit against Walgreens.

To help reduce the spread of COVID-19, most federal courts are working remotely. Unless the courts are further hampered by the virus, with fewer judges available, for example, cases filed under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act might well not be delayed.

In one instance, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania was shuttered indefinitely Wednesday after a law enforcement agent who was in the courthouse was diagnosed with COVID-19, according to a local CBS station. And in the Southern District of New York, the chief judge on Monday placed strict limits on access to court buildings.

“I’ve been getting announcements from various federal district courts across the country, but remote operation seems to be the norm – at least as of today,” Greg Ash, partner at Spencer Fane, said in an email. “I suspect that most pending motions in ERISA (and other) cases will be resolved in the normal course of things, as judges rarely ask for oral argument.”

That could differ for cases in appellate court, as oral arguments are necessary, Mr. Ash noted. In ERISA cases at the circuit court level, oral arguments are rare, he said.

Not all courts have shifted completely to remote work, however.

“Courts have not responded in a uniform fashion to the pandemic,” Marcia Wagner, founder of The Wagner Law Group, wrote in an email. “There are different considerations at the circuit court level, where the primary issue is oral arguments.” For cases without oral arguments, “attorneys do not need to appear in court.”

For cases at district level or in state court that do require juries and oral arguments, operating remotely is not as easy.

Further, some cases will likely see extensions in filing deadlines, including ERISA cases, Ms. Wagner said. “Parties will be seeking extensions from opposing counsel, not specifically related to the litigation, but responding to the pandemic.”

On Monday, a judge denied a motion to dismiss an ERISA case against Walgreens. In that class-action lawsuit, the plaintiffs allege that the plan sponsor breached its fiduciary duty by selecting and retaining a Northern Trust target-date series, rather than products from managers such as Fidelity, Vanguard or T. Rowe Price.

Last Friday, Wells Fargo was sued again over the inclusion of its own products on its 401(k) menu, this time regarding its target-date collective investment trusts. The company had similarly been sued in the past over the mutual fund target-date series previously used in the plan.

And last Thursday, three lead plaintiffs filed a class-action case against BOK Financial, alleging that the bank violated ERISA by including a target-date series and other investment options managed by its Cavanal Hill Investment Management subsidiary in its 401(k). The plan represented about $632 million in assets among more than 6,000 participants as of the end of 2018, according to Department of Labor data available from BrightScope.

Latest News

RIA moves: True North adds $353M California RIA as SageView grows North Carolina presence
RIA moves: True North adds $353M California RIA as SageView grows North Carolina presence

Plus, a $400 million Commonwealth team departs to launch an independent family-run RIA in the East Bay area.

Blue Owl Capital, Voya strike private market partnership for retirement plans
Blue Owl Capital, Voya strike private market partnership for retirement plans

The collaboration will focus initially on strategies within collective investment trusts in DC plans, with plans to expand to other retirement-focused private investment solutions.

Top Commonwealth advisor to recruiters: Stop with the cold calls already!
Top Commonwealth advisor to recruiters: Stop with the cold calls already!

“I respectfully request that all recruiters for other BDs discontinue their efforts to contact me," writes Thomas Bartholomew.

Why AI notetakers alone can't fix 'broken' advisor meetings
Why AI notetakers alone can't fix 'broken' advisor meetings

Wealth tech veteran Aaron Klein speaks out against the "misery" of client meetings, why advisors' communication skills don't always help, and AI's potential to make bad meetings "100 times better."

Morgan Stanley, Goldman, Wells Fargo to settle Archegos trades lawsuit
Morgan Stanley, Goldman, Wells Fargo to settle Archegos trades lawsuit

The proposed $120 million settlement would close the book on a legal challenge alleging the Wall Street banks failed to disclose crucial conflicts of interest to investors.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.