A doctor deconstructs the Affordable Care Act

Five questions for Dr. Carolyn McClanahan, a physician and director of financial planning at Life Planning Partners.
OCT 11, 2013
Fewer advisers have kept a closer eye on the Affordable Care Act than Dr. Carolyn McClanahan, a physician and director of financial planning at Life Planning Partners Inc. Indeed, health care reform has kept her busy: It's been a focal point for a regular column she writes for Forbes in which she answers readers' questions about the ACA. Advisers know that the insurance exchanges are open for business, but now what? InvestmentNews: What do advisers need to know about the exchanges? Ms. McClanahan: The important thing they need to know is which clients may need to buy insurance on the exchanges. There are two types: those who don't have insurance now because they're uninsurable, and those who have costly coverage through work. They need to shop on the exchanges and compare policies. There are three parts to comparing coverage on the exchanges versus what you have now. First, look at the premiums on the exchange policies. They vary depending on the state. [A report by the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation at the Department of Health and Human Services found wide variations in premiums on a state-by-state level, as well as regional differences within the states themselves.] Second, take a look at the coverage and compare that to what you had before. The coverage [on the exchanges] is better, as some existing policies don't cover mental health benefits or pregnancy. The last thing is to compare the copays and the deductibles. InvestmentNews: How do costs on the exchanges compare with what's currently available, now that insurance will be guaranteed regardless of pre-existing conditions? Ms. McClanahan: What people need to understand is that it doesn't matter how sick you are and what problems you have — you can't be turned down. Currently, in some states, insurers will turn you down for something like allergies. On the exchanges, the premiums aren't based on health. Rather, it depends on your age, where you live, the number of people in your family and whether you smoke. Older people won't pay more than three times what younger people are paying. People under 30 can get catastrophic policies, which are very inexpensive. These cover three doctor visits per year and preventive benefits. InvestmentNews: Thirty-six states are expected to participate in the federal insurance exchange. How might the government shutdown affect implementation? Ms. McClanahan: [The administration] is saying that the shutdown won't affect the exchanges, but we don't have the answer to whether the people running the exchanges are part of the essential group of federal employees who are being kept on staff. But the shutdown shouldn't affect the exchanges at all. Right now, millions of people are trying to access the exchange websites and get signed up. As of Wednesday morning, I was able to create an account on Florida's federally run insurance exchange, but I was unable to shop for policies. InvestmentNews: What should small-business owners know about the exchanges? Ms. McClanahan: There have been some delays with the Small Business Health Options Program, or SHOP, marketplace. For instance, a feature that would allow each worker to pick his or her own plan, using funds from the workplace, won't be in place until 2015, and small businesses won't be able to enroll online until November — they can still sign on to check their options. The nice thing about providing coverage as an employer is that it's paid for on a pretax basis. If you were to go buy your own coverage, that's paid after-tax. I'm telling my small-business clients now to wait a year for the SHOP exchanges. They're available now and you can take a look, but this year, let's stick with what you have. As the exchanges expand, you might want to change where you get your insurance. If small businesses aren't offering insurance now, then they should check out the exchanges. InvestmentNews: Are you considering using the SHOP exchanges for your practice's insurance coverage? Ms. McClanahan: We're going to look at it, but for now, we'll stick with what we have.

Latest News

Workers are financially drowning and retirement savings is a major red flag
Workers are financially drowning and retirement savings is a major red flag

Transamerica Institute survey reveals a stark divide between employer confidence and workers' financial reality.

SEC corporate enforcement hits multi-decade low as agency refocuses on fraud
SEC corporate enforcement hits multi-decade low as agency refocuses on fraud

Just five actions were started in the first half of fiscal 2026, a new analysis finds.

Beyond the Business: Why Advisors Must Help Owners Separate Wealth from Identity
Beyond the Business: Why Advisors Must Help Owners Separate Wealth from Identity

For business owners, the company is often more than an income source. It becomes their largest asset, their retirement plan, and in many cases, part of their identity. Advisors who understand that dynamics can deliver far greater value than traditional financial planning alone

Ex-Edward Jones advisor gets three-year prison sentence for stealing from widow
Ex-Edward Jones advisor gets three-year prison sentence for stealing from widow

John S. Winslow, 57, was indicted just over a year ago for his scheme to steal from an elderly client.

Vestmark, Hamachi push AI further for advisor portfolio intelligence
Vestmark, Hamachi push AI further for advisor portfolio intelligence

Hamachi's new model portfolio partnership and an industry-first solution from Vestmark join the growing wave of AI tools for wealth managers.

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management

SPONSORED Durability over scale: What actually defines a great advisory firm

Growth may get the headlines, but in my experience, longevity is earned through structure, culture, and discipline