Advisers praise Sanders for highlighting Social Security, doubt his approach

Advisers praise Sanders for highlighting Social Security, doubt his approach
The Vermont senator proposed lifting the cap on taxable income for the program.
DEC 07, 2015
Investment advisers praised Bernie Sanders for addressing Social Security shortages in Tuesday's Democratic presidential debate, but said his aggressive ideas may not be politically realistic. The independent Vermont senator who calls himself a socialist highlighted his plan to fortify the safety-net program by raising taxes on the wealthy. “The way you expand it is by lifting the cap on taxable incomes so that you do away with the absurdity of a millionaire paying the same amount into the system as somebody making $118,000,” Mr. Sanders said during the debate. “You do that, Social Security is solvent until 2061 and you can expand benefits.” Currently, the Social Security payroll tax is applied to a maximum of $118,500 of income. Under Mr. Sanders' plan, everyone making more than $250,000 annually would pay the same percentage of their earnings into Social Security as those who are lower on the pay scale. That adjustment would increase benefits by an average of $65 per month, according to his campaign. Mr. Sanders' idealism appeals to one investment adviser, who doubts his proposal would ever make it through a Republican-controlled Congress. “His plan for Social Security sounds great,” said Carolyn McClanahan, founder of Life Planning Partners. “I don't know if it's passable.” Scot Hanson, a financial planner at EFS Advisors, gave Mr. Sanders credit for putting Social Security reform on the agenda. “Bernie at least threw out an option,” Mr. Hanson said. “It's something to consider. I'm not sure it's the best answer, but we have to do something.” During the debate, the Democratic front-runner, former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, said she wants to keep Social Security solvent, but was less specific in her comments about the program. “The most important fight we're going to have is defending it against continuing Republican efforts to privatize it,” Ms. Clinton said during the debate. “I want to enhance the benefits for the poorest recipients of Social Security. We have a lot of women on Social Security, particularly widowed and single women who didn't make a lot of money during their careers, and they are impoverished, and they need more help from the Social Security system.” On her campaign website, Ms. Clinton gives little detail about her plans for reforming the old-age pension. But less might be more when it comes to the reality of Social Security politics. “Hers is more tempered, and it's probably easier to pull off in reality,” Ms. McClanahan said of Ms. Clinton's approach. Another Democratic candidate, former Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley, outlines on his campaign website a plan for strengthening retirement security that encompasses expanding Social Security, in part also by raising the income-cap on the payroll tax. Mr. O'Malley didn't elaborate on Social Security during the debate. As part of his retirement-security plan, Mr. O'Malley vows to “fully enforce” a Labor Department rule that would raise investment advice standards for retirement accounts. In her financial reform proposal last week, Ms. Clinton vaguely referenced the pending rule.

Latest News

Federal judge dismisses Eltek manipulation lawsuit against Morgan Stanley Smith Barney
Federal judge dismisses Eltek manipulation lawsuit against Morgan Stanley Smith Barney

Nine-month electronic trading freeze and share lending program at the center of dismissed claim.

RIA wrap: Dynamic strikes South Carolina deal to reach $7B AUM milestone
RIA wrap: Dynamic strikes South Carolina deal to reach $7B AUM milestone

Meanwhile, Rossby Financial's leadership buildout rolls on with a new COO appointment as Balefire Wealth welcomes a distinguished retirement specialist to its national network.

Rethinking diversification amid a concentrated S&P 500
Rethinking diversification amid a concentrated S&P 500

With a smaller group of companies driving stock market performance, advisors must work more intentionally to manage concentration risks within client portfolios.

Merrill pays second settlement to former Miami Dolphins player, client of ex-broker
Merrill pays second settlement to former Miami Dolphins player, client of ex-broker

Professional athletes are often targets of scam artists and are particularly vulnerable to fraud.

Schwab touts AI as its biggest growth lever at investor day
Schwab touts AI as its biggest growth lever at investor day

The brokerage giant tells Wall Street it will use artificial intelligence to reach clients it has never been able to serve — and turn the technology's perceived threat into a competitive edge.

SPONSORED Beyond wealth management: Why the future of advice is becoming more human

As technical expertise becomes increasingly commoditized, advisors who can integrate strategy, relationships, and specialized expertise into a cohesive client experience will define the next era of wealth management

SPONSORED Durability over scale: What actually defines a great advisory firm

Growth may get the headlines, but in my experience, longevity is earned through structure, culture, and discipline