Appeals court sends 401(k) fee case Tibble vs. Edison back to District Court to be reheard

The opinion vacated the Los Angeles District Court's ruling that the case could not proceed because of a statute of limitations on three of six funds in question.
DEC 19, 2016
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco on Friday ordered a U.S. District Court to rehear the Tibble vs. Edison International excessive 401(k) fee case, which centered on the choice of retail vs. institutional investment products. (More: Attorney Jerry Schlichter opens up about 403(b), 401(k) suits) The opinion written by Judge Milan D. Smith Jr. vacated the Los Angeles District Court's ruling that the case could not proceed because of a statute of limitations on three of six funds in question. “Regardless of whether there was a significant change in circumstances, Edison should have switched from retail-class fund shares to institutional-class fund shares to fulfill its continuing duty to monitor the appropriateness of the trust investments … a trustee cannot ignore the power the trust wields to obtain favorable investment products, particularly when those products are substantially identical — other than their lower cost — to products the trustee has already selected.” “We also encourage the District Court to re-evaluate its fee determination in light of the Supreme Court's decision and this court's en banc decision,” Mr. Smith wrote. (More: Supreme Court decision in 401(k) case may have profound effect on fiduciary debate) The 9th Circuit had previously affirmed the District Court's ruling for Edison, which led to the 2015 U.S. Supreme Court ruling in its first 401(k) case alleging excessive fees that trustees have an ongoing duty to monitor plan investments. In April, a three-judge panel for the 9th Circuit ruled in favor of Edison International, but on Aug. 5, the appeals court agreed to the en banc rehearing resulting in the latest order. Hazel Bradford is a reporter with InvestmentNews' sister publication, Pensions & Investments.

Latest News

Advisor AI startup Zeplyn adds ex-LPL leader Kabir Sethi to board
Advisor AI startup Zeplyn adds ex-LPL leader Kabir Sethi to board

The two-decade veteran, whose career also includes a stint at Merill Lynch, will help shape strategy for the Google engineer-founded fintech.

US wholesale inflation surprises on food, energy prices
US wholesale inflation surprises on food, energy prices

The latest PPI print, clocking in north of 3 percent, adds to concerns that inflation is far from tamed.

Robinhood earnings surge as TradePMR acquisition plan rolls along
Robinhood earnings surge as TradePMR acquisition plan rolls along

The DIY investment giant's positive earnings surprise, surpassing $1 billion in revenue for the first time, puts it on strong footing for future expansion.

Advisors expect revenue boost this year as Secure 2.0 provisions kick in
Advisors expect revenue boost this year as Secure 2.0 provisions kick in

Most retirement plan specialists anticipate gain of up to 10%.

Debt has become a way of life for working Americans, report warns
Debt has become a way of life for working Americans, report warns

And they would have to work extra hard to pay it off.

SPONSORED Record growth: Interval funds emerge as key players in alternative investments

Blue Vault Alts Summit highlights the role of liquidity-focused funds in reshaping advisor strategies

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.