Appeals court upholds dismissal of Wells Fargo 401(k) lawsuit

Appeals court upholds dismissal of Wells Fargo 401(k) lawsuit
Participant argued that the plan could have offered a better-performing, nonproprietary TDF.
AUG 06, 2018
A federal appeals court in St. Louis upheld a U.S. District Court judge's dismissal of an ERISA breach claim against Wells Fargo & Co. by a participant in the company's 401(k) plan, who alleged fiduciaries could have offered a better-performing nonproprietary investment choice. The complaint "failed to plausibly allege a breach of fiduciary duty," according to the unanimous ruling by a three-judge panel. "The complaint failed to state a claim upon which relief can be granted." In the case of Meiners et al. vs. Wells Fargo & Co et al., a U.S. District Court Judge in Minneapolis had dismissed the complaint in May 2017. The participant, John Meiners, had argued that including the Wells Fargo Dow Jones Target Date Funds series was an ERISA violation because a similar target-date series from Vanguard Group had better returns. "A comparison of the returns of two different funds is insufficient" to prove a fiduciary breach, U.S. District Court Judge David S. Doty wrote. The Wells Fargo series, he noted, had a higher allocation of bonds than the Vanguard series. "The District Court correctly determined that Meiners' omission of any meaningful benchmark in his complaint mean that he failed to allege any facts showing the Wells Fargo [target-date funds] were an imprudent choice," the appeals court wrote. "As a result, Meiners' complaint failed to state a claim for relief under ERISA and we affirm its dismissal." The Wells Fargo & Co. 401(k) Plan had $45.9 billion in assets as of Dec. 31, 2017, according to its latest 11-K filing. Robert Steyer is a reporter for InvestmentNews' sister publication Pensions & Investments.

Latest News

Judge accused of bias in discrimination case by ex-life insurance employee
Judge accused of bias in discrimination case by ex-life insurance employee

My employer was biased – and the judge and magistrate are being unfair says ex-employee

Best yet to come for ETFs as investors navigate global uncertainty: BBH
Best yet to come for ETFs as investors navigate global uncertainty: BBH

Global survey reveals tailwinds for active ETFs and alternative strategies, plus a turning point in cost-conscious investing.

Nominations for the first-ever 5-Star RIA Firms 2025 now open
Nominations for the first-ever 5-Star RIA Firms 2025 now open

InvestmentNews begins its inaugural search for the top wealth managers in the industry.

Finra hits RIA buyer NewEdge with $1 million penalty over Muni bond trades
Finra hits RIA buyer NewEdge with $1 million penalty over Muni bond trades

The market for municipal bonds is notorious for being opaque and filled with difficult to price securities.

Why these RIA firms are sitting out the M&A trend
Why these RIA firms are sitting out the M&A trend

Leaders at Five Eleven Partners and Johnson Investment Counsel speak out on the costs of consolidation, the pros and cons of PE, and how they're planning ahead for clients and advisors.

SPONSORED Beyond the all-in-one: Why specialization is key in wealth tech

In an industry of broad solutions, firms like intelliflo prove 'you just need tools that play well together'

SPONSORED Record growth: Interval funds emerge as key players in alternative investments

Blue Vault Alts Summit highlights the role of liquidity-focused funds in reshaping advisor strategies