As 401(k) assets fall, investors could pay higher fees

As 401(k) assets fall, investors could pay higher fees
Several factors are moving money out of plans, including provisions in the recently passed CARES Act
APR 13, 2020

Retirement plans are on track to lose considerable assets this year, which could lead to higher record keeping costs for some participants.

Several factors are moving money out of plans, including provisions in the recently passed Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act, which allows savers affected by COVID-19 to take early distributions or account loans. Market losses have also eroded plan assets.

That is significant for participants in plans that pay tiered, asset-based record keeping fees, as some will inevitably go below thresholds that previously got them discounts.

“We’re going to see plans repriced immediately,” said Jason Roberts, CEO of the Pension Resource Institute. And because of the new withdrawal provisions under the CARES Act, “We’re going to see a trailing impact for three years. People can keep that money out and not pay taxes.”

And workers, especially those who are struggling financially and not eligible for a company match, will be less likely to contribute to their plans, he said.

Defined contribution plans that pay for record keeping through asset-based fees do so through one of three different arrangements, said Chris Thixton, principal at Pension Consultants, Inc. Those categories are either a single asset-based fee, a tiered fee based on total plan assets, or a “first-next” arrangement in which one fee applies to a certain level of assets and lesser fees apply to assets above that amount, Thixton said.

“There’s no standardization in this industry in terms of how fees are assessed,” he said.

Plans with a tiered fee schedule, which lowers record keeping costs across all assets when a certain level is reached, would be most affected by falling asset levels, he said. However, that arrangement is less common today than it once was, he noted.

Declining 401(k) assets “definitely could affect [fees], just automatically,” he said. But, “a lot of those are older types of arrangements.”

Plans with a single asset-based fee probably won’t be affected, he said. Those with first-next tiered pricing could see less of a discount on assets that are above a certain level, but that might not be noticeable to many participants.

But there will likely be a consequence for many 401(k) plans in the coming months and years, Thixton said. Plan providers will almost certainly be hesitant to compete on cost in the same way they have since the 2008 financial crisis, meaning that plan sponsors will have difficulty renegotiating for lower fees, he said.

“We want fees to be low — not just reasonable … If we keep our fees low, every dollar we save is another dollar for retirement,” he said. “[But] this is in general not a time to go and renegotiate your fees.”

In the next few years, “we’re not going to have as many price reductions” approved by record keepers, he said.

Plans have become less expensive for participants since the financial crisis, due to both lower investment expenses and administrative fees, according to data from the Investment Company Institute and BrightScope. On an asset-weighted basis, total plan costs went from an average of 47 basis points in 2009 to 39 bps in 2016, according to a report published last year by those groups.

Plan providers will be discouraged this year from raising fees for clients whose assets fell below thresholds, said Michael Coelho, managing director of SageView Advisory Group.

“This is a terrible PR move — I don’t think they will raise fees because of shrinking assets,” Coelho said. “I don’t think they’re going to penalize participants in this environment.”

That could mean a grace period for plan sponsors, during which time they will continue to receive discounted pricing that was associated with higher asset levels in plans, he said.

That could also apply to investments, such as collective investment trusts, he noted. Conversely, plans that were very close to receiving discounts before the market free fall will be unlikely to get them, he said.

Going forward, record keepers will most likely use more realistic pricing levels than they have in the past, he said.

“Before, employers and employees had all the leverage,” he said. “Fees were falling so fast, [for plan providers] to stay competitive. Record keepers were kind of at [the plan sponsors’] mercy.”

Record keepers will also likely emphasize the suite of participant services they have developed, as part of the overall move toward financial wellness, he said.

“Financial wellness has yet to be monetized,” he said. “Plan sponsors are really valuing that service more than they ever have.”

Latest News

JPMorgan tells fintech firms to start paying for customer data
JPMorgan tells fintech firms to start paying for customer data

The move to charge data aggregators fees totaling hundreds of millions of dollars threatens to upend business models across the industry.

FINRA snapshot shows concentration in largest firms, coastal states
FINRA snapshot shows concentration in largest firms, coastal states

The latest snapshot report reveals large firms overwhelmingly account for branches and registrants as trend of net exits from FINRA continues.

Why advisors to divorcing couples shouldn't bet on who'll stay
Why advisors to divorcing couples shouldn't bet on who'll stay

Siding with the primary contact in a marriage might make sense at first, but having both parties' interests at heart could open a better way forward.

SEC spanks closed Osaic RIA for conflicts, over-charging clients on alternatives
SEC spanks closed Osaic RIA for conflicts, over-charging clients on alternatives

With more than $13 billion in assets, American Portfolios Advisors closed last October.

William Blair taps former Raymond James executive to lead investment management business
William Blair taps former Raymond James executive to lead investment management business

Robert D. Kendall brings decades of experience, including roles at DWS Americas and a former investment unit within Morgan Stanley, as he steps into a global leadership position.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.