Cross-selling poised to be next 401(k) 'battleground' issue

Cross-selling poised to be next 401(k) 'battleground' issue
Advisers selling wealth management or financial wellness services should be careful, according to experts.
MAY 13, 2019

Cross-selling products and services to 401(k) plan participants — on the part of both record keepers and financial advisers — is shaping up to be among the most contentious issues in the retirement-plan market. The issue comes down to the use of participants' data: Should service providers and advisers be able to use individuals' information, such as investment choices and proximity to retirement, to market and sell non-retirement-plan-related products to them? "This is going to be the next battleground," said Philip Chao, principal and chief investment officer at Chao & Co. "This whole [data] ownership idea is critical." The issue around investors' 401(k) information plays into broader discussions playing out globally about how technology companies such as Facebook collect and leverage user data. The European Union has clamped down on data protection with its General Data Protection Regulation. Data has clearly become a more prominent part of the retirement industry, too, as both record keepers and asset managers tout the benefits of more personalized investing via managed accounts and personalized financial advice in a financial wellness context. The tension around 401(k) data usage was exposed recently in a lawsuit claiming Vanderbilt University mismanaged its retirement plan. Vanderbilt settled the case, and agreed as part of that settlement to tell Fidelity Investments, the plan's record keeper, to refrain from using participants' information to cross-sell unrelated products and services. (That is, unless participants request Fidelity do so.) Legal experts said they had never before seen a similar provision in settlements of other retirement-plan lawsuits. In a separate lawsuit against Northwestern University, plaintiffs said record keeper TIAA had inappropriately used data such as contact information, asset size of account, employment status and age to market other products. That lawsuit was dismissed, but is being appealed. Barbara Delaney, principal at StoneStreet Advisor Group, said several record keepers engage in this type of conduct, as a way to boost their revenue in the face of declining fees. "It's becoming an issue," Ms. Delaney said. "They cut their margins so thin they feel like they have to sell other products." David Levine, principal at Groom Law Group, said the central issue is whether data is a "plan asset," a term that's not defined under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974. Some parties clearly believe it is a material issue, given terms of the Vanderbilt settlement, said Mr. Levine. The issue's implications go beyond record keepers — financial advisers upselling ancillary services such as wealth management and financial wellness to retirement-plan participants could find themselves in the crosshairs of plaintiffs, too, Mr. Levine said. And it's not just ERISA that record keepers and advisers should be wary of — there are also state laws such as California's Consumer Privacy Act signed last year, as well as federal laws such as the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (which pertains to sharing and protection of consumers' private information), and even the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, if advisers are doing work with health savings accounts. "This goes to a much bigger type of discussion," Mr. Levine said. "There's a lot of data at the center of this industry." To Mr. Chao, the central issue is about conflict — do companies have the right to use personal information to sell more product? "We don't have an answer," he said. "This is still a fairly new area."

Latest News

SEC Says Game Service Roblox Part of ‘Active Investigation’
SEC Says Game Service Roblox Part of ‘Active Investigation’

Short sellers previously said the company was under investigation, though Roblox denied allegations.

Musk’s DOGE descends on CFPB with intention to shut it down
Musk’s DOGE descends on CFPB with intention to shut it down

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is in the crosshairs of the Republican group that is widely attempting to dismantle government agencies.

Advisor fighting Finra banishment loses $17.7 million dispute with old firm
Advisor fighting Finra banishment loses $17.7 million dispute with old firm

National Securities Corp. sued the advisor in 2020, alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment.

Job numbers, inflation leaving room for Fed to hold rates
Job numbers, inflation leaving room for Fed to hold rates

Recent data support a measured pace by the Federal Reserve for the year ahead.

Private assets remain hot despite surging stock market
Private assets remain hot despite surging stock market

Financial advisors are still adding alternatives despite the surge in publicly traded stock prices

SPONSORED Taylor Matthews on what's behind Farther's rapid growth

From 'no clients' to reshaping wealth management, Farther blends tech and trust to deliver family-office experience at scale.

SPONSORED Why wealth advisors should care about the future of federal tax policy

Blue Vault features expert strategies to harness for maximum client advantage.