ESG still scant in DC plans, used more in public sector

ESG still scant in DC plans, used more in public sector
ESG is only used in 5% of corporate DC plans, according to Callan. Use by institutional investors also varies a lot by geography.
NOV 10, 2021

There is an enormous gap in ESG use between public and private retirement plans, survey data published by the Callan Institute show.

About one in 20 corporate defined-contribution plans includes an investment option that is labeled as an environmental, social and governance product, according to the new report. By comparison, 43% of public and nonprofit DC plans include such options. ESG investments also represent a small slice of all DC plan assets, at an average of 1.2%.

A forthcoming rule from the Department of Labor could change that. Last month, the regulator published a proposed rule that would walk back regulations finalized at the end of the Trump administration that had a chilling effect on the use of ESG in 401(k)s and other plans. Under the Biden administration, the DOL is making clear that ESG factors are financially material considerations that plan fiduciaries can or should make.

Crucially, the regulator is reversing its stance on the use of ESG in the default investments in retirement plans, such as target-date funds. Under a rule finalized last year, those investments were prohibited outright.

That change alone has the potential to give ESG a considerable boost within DC plans.

In its survey in May and June of 114 U.S. institutional investors, Callan found that 40% of entities that have not previously used ESG said that they are now considering it. Among those that have, 55% described the decision to do so as a way to bring their portfolios in line with their values.

The survey included responses from DC and defined-benefit plan sponsors, endowments and foundations, and plan sizes ranged from small to as big as $20 billion.

Across the different plan types, the sectors that were most likely to include ESG were government (63%), nonprofits (57%), education (50%) and financial services (40%), according to Callan.

Although nearly half of all respondents said they incorporate ESG criteria in their investments, the majority (55%) of those that have said they started that practice between 2016 and this year, the survey found.

The report also found that larger entities are considerably more likely to use ESG than smaller ones.

But geography is also a factor. While 63% of respondents in the Northeast use ESG, just 38% of those in the Central states do so, Callan found. The rates are 42% in the Southeast, 40% in the Mountain states and 50% on the West Coast.

Latest News

‘No detractor’ to using direct indexing as an investment strategy
‘No detractor’ to using direct indexing as an investment strategy

Thirty four percent of advisors surveyed by InvestmentNews say they use direct indexing strategies but 39 percent don’t.

After watching advisors bolt, B. Riley now losing investment bankers
After watching advisors bolt, B. Riley now losing investment bankers

“This is on the B. Riley Securities side of the business, the dealmaking side,” one senior industry executive said.

Does sell and stay really work?
Does sell and stay really work?

There are three essential elements you must bring to the table to increase the chances of a successful post-sale career.

Retirement savings rise with two account types posting record highs
Retirement savings rise with two account types posting record highs

Across generations, how are savers doing with their 401(k) contributions?

What's making America's billionaires richer, faster?
What's making America's billionaires richer, faster?

New report shines some light on today's billionaires' investments.

SPONSORED How MRP’s Synthetic Equity is balancing growth and protection for advisors

"Synth Equity has been such a tailwind for these advisors who really understand the story," Measured Risk Portfolios’ head of distribution said.

SPONSORED The future of prospecting: Say goodbye to cold calls and hello to smart connections

Streamline your outreach with Aidentified's AI-driven solutions