Federal auto-IRA would crowd out private-sector plans, critics say

Federal auto-IRA would crowd out private-sector plans, critics say
'Why would any business owner maintain a retirement plan if the federal government is going to take over all the costs and responsibility of providing retirement benefits?' says the CEO of a trade group representing plan sponsors.
OCT 23, 2023

A federal automatic retirement savings program would undermine retirement plans offered by businesses to their employees, said critics of new federal legislation.

Sens. John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.) and Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) last week introduced the Retirement Savings for America Act, which would establish portable, tax-advantaged retirement accounts sponsored by the federal government. Low- and middle-income workers who use the accounts would be eligible for a contribution match from the government that would phase out at the median income level.

A trade group representing retirement plan sponsors is resisting the idea.

“Why would any business owner maintain a retirement plan if the federal government is going to take over all the costs and responsibility of providing retirement benefits?” said Brian Graff, CEO of the American Retirement Association. “They are creating an unlevel playing field where the federal product is unfairly subsidized relative to the private sector.”

The federal government doesn’t need a new retirement program when the one already in place — Social Security — needs to be fixed, said Angela Antonelli, a research professor at Georgetown University and executive director of the Center for Retirement Initiatives at its McCourt School of Public Policy.

“There is no need for the bill,” Antonelli said. “The federal government instead should be focused on Social Security’s fiscal sustainability.”

Under the Hickenlooper bill, the full- and part-time workers who don't have access to a company retirement plan would be eligible for an account and automatically enrolled at 3% of their income, according to a fact sheet about the bill. Worker could increase or decrease their contribution and opt out at any time.

Low- and moderate-income workers would be eligible for a 1% automatic federal contribution and up to 4% matching contribution through a refundable federal tax credit. Workers could carry the accounts from job to job.

Reps. Lloyd Smucker (R-Pa.) and Terri Sewell (D-Ala.) are expected to introduce a companion bill in the House.

“Americans who work hard their entire lives deserve to retire with dignity,” Hickenlooper said in a statement. “This bill helps low-income workers enjoy a secure retirement and fulfill their American dream.”

A Hickenlooper spokesperson was not immediately available to respond to criticism about the bill.

The Insured Retirement Institute said it shares the goal of expanding retirement savings opportunities for more Americans but favors different legislation for doing so. The IRI supports an automatic individual retirement account bill that has been introduced in previous congressional sessions by Rep. Richard Neal, D-Mass.

The bill Neal floated in 2021 would require employers with five or more employees that don’t offer retirement plans to enroll their workers automatically in IRAs or 401(k)-type plans. The measure offered a tax credit to offset costs but also imposed an excise tax on businesses that don’t set establish retirement programs.

“It’s a private-sector solution versus a government solution,” said Paul Richman, IRI chief government and political affairs officer. The Neal bill has not been reintroduced in the current congressional session.

IRI, which represents annuity providers, hasn’t taken a position on the Hickenlooper bill. But Richman said its price tag — about $40 billion annually — may prevent it from getting much support in a Congress riven with divisions over funding the federal government.

“It seems to me in the current political environment we don’t have a consensus among the members of Congress to start spending more money when they’re talking about cutting other programs, particularly on the Republican side of the aisle in both chambers,” he said.

Many states have established auto-IRA programs, which generally require employers that don’t offer a retirement plan to allow their workers to sign up for the state plan. The businesses’ role is administrative and they don’t contribute to the plans.

Instead of establishing its own auto-IRA, the federal government should “support the expansion of private-sector retirement plans in combination with the new state initiatives,” Antonelli said.

Economy set to rise slowly, not land softly, says Thrivent CIO

Latest News

Northern Trust names new West Region president for wealth
Northern Trust names new West Region president for wealth

The new regional leader brings nearly 25 years of experience as the firm seeks to tap a complex and evolving market.

Capital Group extends retirement plan services further with a focus on advisors
Capital Group extends retirement plan services further with a focus on advisors

The latest updates to its recordkeeping platform, including a solution originally developed for one large 20,000-advisor client, take aim at the small to medium-sized business space.

Why RIAs are the next growth frontier for annuities
Why RIAs are the next growth frontier for annuities

David Lau, founder and CEO of DPL Financial Partners, explains how the RIA boom and product innovation has fueled a slow-burn growth story in annuities.

Supreme Court slaps down challenge to IRS summons for Coinbase user data
Supreme Court slaps down challenge to IRS summons for Coinbase user data

Crypto investor argues the federal agency's probe, upheld by a federal appeals court, would "strip millions of Americans of meaningful privacy protections."

Houston-based RIA Americana Partners adds $1B+ with former Morgan Stanley director
Houston-based RIA Americana Partners adds $1B+ with former Morgan Stanley director

Meanwhile in Chicago, the wirehouse also lost another $454 million team as a group of defectors moved to Wells Fargo.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.