Georgia court refuses to dismiss 401(k) suit, citing SCOTUS Northwestern decision

Georgia court refuses to dismiss 401(k) suit, citing SCOTUS Northwestern decision
The case filed against the Columbus Regional Health System cited breaches similar to those alleged in the Northwestern case, such as offering retail share classes of mutual funds instead of lower-cost institutional shares.
JAN 31, 2022

A federal district court in Georgia refused to dismiss a 401(k) lawsuit filed against the Columbus Regional Healthcare System, and it cited the Supreme Court's ruling last week in Hughes v. Northwestern University in its decision.

The Supreme Court overturned a lower court's dismissal of the lawsuit against Northwestern, ruling that the lower court had put too much weight on the Northwestern plans’ inclusion of some low-cost options as a sign that the plans' fiduciaries abided by their duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act.

The lawsuit filed against the North Carolina-based Columbus Regional Healthcare System also cited breaches of the organization's fiduciary duties to its retirement plan similar to those alleged in the Northwestern case, including offering the retail share classes of mutual funds instead of identical, but lower-cost, institutional shares; selecting and retaining underperforming funds; and overpaying for record-keeping services.

In its decision, the Georgia court “also rejected defendant’s argument that plaintiffs’ claims should be dismissed in part because the plan offered a variety of investment options that participants could select, including lower-cost passive investment options,” according to a blog from the Proskauer law firm. “The district court explained that Hughes rejected this exact argument in holding that a fiduciary’s decisions are not insulated merely by giving participants choice over their investments and that fiduciaries have a continuing duty to monitor plan investments.”

Latest News

Easy to buy, harder to exit: The liquidity risk hidden inside ETFs
Easy to buy, harder to exit: The liquidity risk hidden inside ETFs

Getting a client into a fund has never been easier – but after that, the hardest part is yet to come.

FINRA bars NYLIFE rep who used smart glasses to cheat on Series 6
FINRA bars NYLIFE rep who used smart glasses to cheat on Series 6

A former NYLIFE Securities rep was permanently barred after using internet-enabled glasses to cheat on the Series 6 exam

Vanguard settled Just Invest lawsuit weeks before Altruist deal
Vanguard settled Just Invest lawsuit weeks before Altruist deal

Both of Vanguard's acquisitions have targeted the RIA industry, but the first ended in a legal settlement just weeks before buying Altruist.

Ex-Raymond James duo launch Proxima on Concurrent's platform
Ex-Raymond James duo launch Proxima on Concurrent's platform

Chris Davitt and Anupam Singh bring institutional recruiting muscle to a firm built for advisors chasing equity and independence.

Osaic names Sayee Bellamkonda as first chief AI and technology officer
Osaic names Sayee Bellamkonda as first chief AI and technology officer

Appointment continues a wave of AI leadership hires reshaping wealth management as advisory firms race to build out digital and data infrastructure.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income