HSAs functioning more as 401(k)s

The tax-advantaged health savings accounts can be a useful way to salt away money.
SEP 01, 2018
By  Sarah Min

Retirement plan advisers are increasingly interested in helping employer clients with their health savings accounts. But how should advisers look at these accounts? That depends on whether the employer wants to position the HSA as a transactional account or an investment account. "They need to start with that question and then build up," said Aaron Pottichen, president of retirement services at CLS Partners. For high-income clients who don't need to withdraw money from their HSAs for current medical expenses, investing in these triple-tax-advantaged accounts can be a particularly useful way to salt away money for medical costs in retirement, according to advisers. If clients can afford to turn HSAs from transactional accounts into investment portfolios more like 401(k)s, they can accumulate savings quickly. The average HSA investment account has an average total balance of $16,457, which is more than eight times larger than a non-investment holder's average account balance, according to a 2017 annual report published by Devenir Group.

Risk-averse employees

For companies with more conservative employees — for example, blue-collar workers who may be more risk-averse or may not actively invest — advisers should consider having the investments in an HSA mirror those in the 401(k) lineup, said Eric Remjeske, president and co-founder of Devenir. Such an approach provides familiarity and continuity, and eliminates guesswork, he said. However, that approach may not offer much to companies with more investment-savvy employees, such as financial services companies, law firms and traditionally higher-income industries where employees already actively invest. "More sophisticated employer groups may find it more helpful to have more options to diversify into," Mr. Remjeske said. All HSA funds should include "need to have" asset classes, such as U.S. large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap equity funds, according to a Devenir HSA best practices report. They also should have international equity funds and U.S. intermediate or multisector fixed-income funds. Advisers and employers can also broaden portfolios to include emerging-market equities, target-date funds and specialty bonds. If the portfolios expand even further, they can include alternative funds and international fixed-income funds. "Investment menus should account for various needs that people have," Mr. Remjeske said. Compared to the investment options in 401(k)s, investments in HSAs historically have been seen as subpar in quality — they've been considered expensive and seen as underperformers that don't have many asset classes available, according to advisers. Read more: Comparing the 401(k) vs HSA  However, according to a Devenir analysis, 89.7% of HSA funds were among the cheapest 50% of all mutual funds in their respective Morningstar investment categories. "The myth is that the funds being offered are expensive funds, and we're showing that relative to the marketplace, they're not," Mr. Remjeske said. Vincent Morris, president at Bukaty Cos., an employee benefits and insurance brokerage firm that has about 6,000 HSA accounts and $52 million in assets under administration, recommends active management for HSAs. For one, it shifts the burden of an investment strategy from a novice to a professional, he said. For another, it allows the adviser to go in and customize an individualized investment strategy based on health, rather than age. Mr. Morris argues that this is a key difference between the investment strategies for HSAs and 401(k)s. "If a person is 65 and healthy, they could potentially leave their HSA to accumulate aggressively," he said. ​

Latest News

In an AI world, investors still look for the human touch
In an AI world, investors still look for the human touch

AI is no replacement for trusted financial advisors, but it can meaningfully enhance their capabilities as well as the systems they rely on.

This viral motivational speaker can also be your Prudential financial advisor
This viral motivational speaker can also be your Prudential financial advisor

Prudential's Jordan Toma is no "Finfluencer," but he is a registered financial advisor with four million social media followers and a message of overcoming personal struggles that's reached kids in 150 school across the US.

Fintech bytes: GReminders and Advisor CRM announce AI-related updates
Fintech bytes: GReminders and Advisor CRM announce AI-related updates

GReminders is deepening its integration partnership with a national wealth firm, while Advisor CRM touts a free new meeting tool for RIAs.

SEC charges barred ex-Merrill broker behind Bain Capital private equity fraud
SEC charges barred ex-Merrill broker behind Bain Capital private equity fraud

The Texas-based former advisor reportedly bilked clients out of millions of dollars, keeping them in the dark with doctored statements and a fake email domain.

Trump's tax bill passes senate in hard-fought victory for Republicans
Trump's tax bill passes senate in hard-fought victory for Republicans

The $3.3 trillion tax and spending cut package narrowly got through the upper house, with JD Vance casting the deciding vote to overrule three GOP holdouts.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.