Industry rails against claims the 401(k) should be "retired'

Providers of 401(k) plans have lambasted a critical article published Oct. 9 in Time magazine denouncing the 401(k) system.
DEC 08, 2009
By  Bloomberg
Providers of 401(k) plans have lambasted a critical article published Oct. 9 in Time magazine denouncing the 401(k) system. In “Why It's Time to Retire the 401(k),” Stephen Gandel argued that the 401(k) system isn't a sufficient vehicle to replace defined-benefit plans as the only way for employees to save for retirement. “The ugly truth ... is that the 401(k) is a lousy idea, a financial flop, a rotten repository for our retirement reserves,” he wrote in the article. “In a system in which one year's gains build on the next, the disaster of 2008 will dent retirement savings long after the recession ends.” Mr. Gandel didn't respond to an e-mail seeking comment on his article. Retirement system advocates, however, have been letting their own comments fly. The Profit Sharing/401k Council of America, for one, took to the web the day after the article was published, disputing many of the points brought up in the story. In a blog post “Time Magazine 401(k) Article: Advocacy Dressed up in Journalism,” PSCA president David Wray argued that the article is filled with misrepresentations. Among them, he wrote, is the article's claim that the average 401(k) account balance is $45,519. That's misleading because Mr. Gandel failed to point out that the “typical 401(k) participant has only eight or nine years of participation with their current employer,” Mr. Wray wrote. The article also didn't take into account the billions of dollars rolled into individual retirement accounts from 401(k) plans, he wrote. The PSCA also wrote a letter to Time disputing several points. Putnam Investments' president and chief executive, Robert L. Reynolds, also wrote a letter to Time, arguing similar points. “What really surprised us was how out-of-date the article was,” Mr. Reynolds said in an interview. “It failed to mention the Pension Protection Act of 2006, which brought to the forefront so many things.” In an Oct. 14 blog post, “Bad facts, bad story,” Stephen Utkus, principal at the Center for Retirement Research at The Vanguard Group Inc., also took issue with Mr. Gandel's portrayal of the DB system as a good solution. “Even in their heyday, the mid-1970s, traditional pensions covered only 40% of private workers. Benefits varied widely — from meager plans paying little to very generous ones,” Mr. Utkus wrote. Financial advisers and consultants gave the Time article mixed reviews. Although Don Stone, president of Plan Sponsor Advisors, a 401(k) plan consultant, said he thinks that the article was “just trying to be sensational,” some advisers thought it might help convince employers to talk more to employees about their retirement savings. Marcia A. Mantel, principal at Mantell Retirement Consulting Inc., said that she plans to use the article when talking with employers about educating plan participants. “Employers need to do more,” she said. “I'm not advocating restarting your pension plan, but they need to bring in more education and get employees to go these sessions.” E-mail Jessica Toonkel Marquez at [email protected].

Latest News

LPL adds $600M UBS team in Tennessee
LPL adds $600M UBS team in Tennessee

The firm's latest additions, led by a second-generation financial advisor, are striking out via its Linsco employee advisor channel.

eMoney supports focused financial planning with enhanced needs analysis
eMoney supports focused financial planning with enhanced needs analysis

The Fidelity-owned fintech aims to help advisors connect with mass market and mass affluent prospects with single-goal conversations.

Trump SEC pick Paul Atkins grilled by Democrats in early political test
Trump SEC pick Paul Atkins grilled by Democrats in early political test

The prospective chair of the agency has pledged to shed conflicted interests and "return common sense to the SEC."

Finra moves to boot Alpine Securities, same firm that claims the regulator can’t
Finra moves to boot Alpine Securities, same firm that claims the regulator can’t

'If I were on the side of Alpine Securities, I’d put all my eggs in the federal court,' one attorney said.

CFP Board floats new procedural rules around bankruptcy, misdemeanors
CFP Board floats new procedural rules around bankruptcy, misdemeanors

If approved, the proposed revisions would achieve outcomes similar to the existing process while reducing the burden of oversight.

SPONSORED Retirement plan balances are flourishing. Why are so many advisors missing out on a $3 trillion opportunity?

Participants who receive professional 401(k) advice see higher returns on average, net, than those who don't.

SPONSORED Focus on clients, not compliance – why Gary Corderman found his fit with Farther

This wealth management platform finally delivers on the technology promises other firms couldn't - giving advisors a better way to scale and serve