IRA conversions surge ahead of tax break end

More Americans than ever converted their tax-deferred IRAs into Roth plans in 2010, led by IRA holders with annual incomes exceeding $1 million. Advisers successfully pitched the switch as a pay now, save later strategy.
JAN 29, 2014
Tax Break for IRA Conversion Lured 10% of Millionaires Congress dangled an incentive for high-income Americans to convert their tax-deferred individual retirement accounts into post-tax plans. Their response was overwhelming. Conversions from regular IRAs to Roth retirement accounts increased more than nine times in 2010, rising to $64.8 billion from $6.8 billion in 2009, according to data released Friday by the Internal Revenue Service. That marked the first time Roth conversions were greater than contributions. Conversions were especially common among IRA holders with annual incomes exceeding $1 million. More than 10% of them converted to a Roth account, the IRS said. The increase in conversions stemmed from a 2006 law that set 2010 for ending a $100,000 income limit on Roth conversions. There's no ceiling on conversions if an investor has multiple IRAs and no cap on the amount that can be shifted. “There was a rush of interest in 2010,” when the restrictions on conversions were lifted, said Thomas Rowley, director of retirement business strategies for Atlanta-based Invesco Ltd. Wealthy investors could better manage their tax liability in retirement and pass the Roth accounts to heirs free of income tax, he said. ESTATE PLANNING “It's the cheapest estate planning you can find,” Mr. Rowley said. “You're paying the taxes for these beneficiaries.” Taxpayers also could split the taxes owed because of the conversions between their 2011 and 2012 returns, giving them until early 2013 before they had to pay the full balance. Wealth advisers pitched Roth conversions to their clients as a pay-now, save-later strategy. Taxpayers with incomes exceeding $1 million made up 4% of the 869,400 Roth conversions in 2010; they moved $14.4 billion, or 22% of the money. When Congress passed the law, the Joint Committee on Taxation estimated that it would raise $6.4 billion for the U.S. government over 10 years. Because Congress looks only at the revenue effects for the first decade, changes that make retirement tax breaks more generous in the long run can be used to offset tax cuts. At the time, the Tax Policy Center estimated that the break would cost the government the net present value of $15 billion in revenue over the long run. Congress passed a similar law in 2013 allowing for easier conversions into Roth 401(k) accounts. Both changes to Roth plan rules were a “classic budget timing gimmick,” said Ed Lorenzen, senior policy adviser at the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget and a former House Democratic aide. LATER LOSSES “You know by its very design it's going to be raising revenues now and losing revenues later,” Mr. Lorenzen said. “It's usually done purely for the purposes of meeting budget rules to appear to be generating revenues.” Contributions to a regular IRA are tax-deferred, with up-front deductions and taxes owed when the money is withdrawn from the account. In contrast, Roth accounts are built with post-tax money. Account holders owe no taxes when they withdraw the money and don't have to make withdrawals once they reach age 70 1/2. Assets in individual retirement accounts, known as IRAs, totaled $6 trillion as of Sept. 30, according to the Investment Company Institute. Almost 4 out of 10 U.S. households owned IRAs in 2013, ICI data show. About 16% of U.S. households, or 19 million, have Roth IRAs compared with about 36 million owners of traditional IRAs in 2013, according to ICI. Roth IRAs, named for former Senate Finance Committee Chairman William Roth of Delaware, were first available in 1998, ICI said. (Bloomberg)

Latest News

Fund fees continue long-term slide as investors favor lower-cost options
Fund fees continue long-term slide as investors favor lower-cost options

Industry report details decades-long trends in expense ratios, 2024 fee movements, and how shifts in advisor compensation have played a role.

Senate Majority Leader pushes full repeal of estate tax
Senate Majority Leader pushes full repeal of estate tax

The Republican leader's call to end the death tax, part of a long and growing wish list of cuts and reductions, would offer relief to a small but important sliver of America's wealthiest taxpayers.

Wall Street bonuses surged 32% to $47.5B last year, NY comptroller says
Wall Street bonuses surged 32% to $47.5B last year, NY comptroller says

The 2024 bump in bonuses made for the largest total pool in records going back to 1987, but economic uncertainty and federal changes weigh on this year's outlook.

Advisors seek transparency on DIY investing as Robinhood faces investigation
Advisors seek transparency on DIY investing as Robinhood faces investigation

'I feel like they have created an addictive gaming culture, which is not healthy for investing.'

Dynasty forges RIA custody partnership with Goldman Sachs
Dynasty forges RIA custody partnership with Goldman Sachs

The collaboration gives Dynasty's $105 billion network of over 500 advisors access to new custodial services, asset management, and lending expertise.

SPONSORED Focus on clients, not compliance – why Gary Corderman found his fit with Farther

This wealth management platform finally delivers on the technology promises other firms couldn't - giving advisors a better way to scale and serve

SPONSORED Beyond the all-in-one: Why specialization is key in wealth tech

In an industry of broad solutions, firms like intelliflo prove 'you just need tools that play well together'