Lawsuit vs. ESG investing in 401(k) plans marks courts’ first test after Chevron ruling

Lawsuit vs. ESG investing in 401(k) plans marks courts’ first test after Chevron ruling
A New Orleans-based appeals court is set to decide on a DOL rule that could impact $12T and more than 150 million workers and retirees in retirement plans.
JUL 08, 2024

A lawsuit challenging a Biden administration rule permitting socially conscious investing by employee retirement plans will test the courts' approach to federal regulations following a pivotal Supreme Court decision.

The New Orleans-based 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals will hear arguments from 25 Republican-led states opposing the Department of Labor's rule on Tuesday, reported Reuters.

The rule in question allows 401(k) and other retirement plans to consider ESG factors as a "tiebreaker" in investment decisions. At the heart of the case is whether the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 permits retirement plans to factor in non-financial considerations. The Labor Department contends that the law does not explicitly prohibit considering ESG factors, provided that financial interests are prioritized.

Conservatives have criticized the rule, arguing that incorporating a political agenda into investment decisions jeopardizes workers' retirement savings. The regulation impacts plans managing $12 trillion on behalf of over 150 million workers and retirees.

In 2022, US District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk in Amarillo, Texas, declined to block the rule, invoking the Chevron deference doctrine. This 1984 Supreme Court precedent directed courts to uphold agencies' reasonable interpretations of the laws they enforce.

However, the Supreme Court overturned Chevron in a significant June decision, requiring judges to exercise independent judgment when evaluating agency rules. This shift is expected to broadly affect the federal government's ability to enact rules through various agencies.

The upcoming case provides the 5th Circuit with an opportunity to interpret the Supreme Court's directive on independent judicial review and establish a framework for assessing challenges to agency rules.

The 5th Circuit, considered the most conservative US appeals court, has frequently disregarded the Chevron doctrine in recent years, blocking several Biden administration regulations. Notably, all three judges on the panel set to hear the case on Tuesday were appointed by Republican presidents.

Katherine Kohn, a Washington, DC-based lawyer at Thompson Hine specializing in employee benefits, noted that the Supreme Court's recent decision could influence the outcome.

"If the 5th Circuit is inclined to vacate the rule, there is probably a path for that even if we were still living under Chevron, although the Loper Bright decision certainly makes it simpler for the 5th Circuit to side with the states," she told Reuters, referring to the Supreme Court ruling from June.

Latest News

The 2025 InvestmentNews Awards Excellence Awardees revealed
The 2025 InvestmentNews Awards Excellence Awardees revealed

From outstanding individuals to innovative organizations, find out who made the final shortlist for top honors at the IN awards, now in its second year.

Top RIA Cresset warns of 'inevitable' recession amid tariff uncertainty
Top RIA Cresset warns of 'inevitable' recession amid tariff uncertainty

Cresset's Susie Cranston is expecting an economic recession, but says her $65 billion RIA sees "great opportunity" to keep investing in a down market.

Edward Jones joins the crowd to sell more alternative investments
Edward Jones joins the crowd to sell more alternative investments

“There’s a big pull to alternative investments right now because of volatility of the stock market,” Kevin Gannon, CEO of Robert A. Stanger & Co., said.

Record RIA M&A activity marks strong start to 2025
Record RIA M&A activity marks strong start to 2025

Sellers shift focus: It's not about succession anymore.

IB+ Data Hub offers strategic edge for U.S. wealth advisors and RIAs advising business clients
IB+ Data Hub offers strategic edge for U.S. wealth advisors and RIAs advising business clients

Platform being adopted by independent-minded advisors who see insurance as a core pillar of their business.

SPONSORED Compliance in real time: Technology's expanding role in RIA oversight

RIAs face rising regulatory pressure in 2025. Forward-looking firms are responding with embedded technology, not more paperwork.

SPONSORED Advisory firms confront crossroads amid historic wealth transfer

As inheritances are set to reshape client portfolios and next-gen heirs demand digital-first experiences, firms are retooling their wealth tech stacks and succession models in real time.