Make clients aware of filial laws that could wreak havoc on the financial security of millions

Encourage clients to think ahead about how much financial responsibility they're willing to assume for their aging parents.
JUN 05, 2016
By  MFXFeeder
Longer life expectancies, coupled with skyrocketing nursing home costs, mean more retirees face the prospect of outliving their savings. The situation also jeopardizes the retirement security of their children, many of whom are members of the “sandwich generation,” who are supporting not only their children but their parents as well. Going forward, some of these adult children could find themselves forced to dip into their own retirement nest eggs to pay for their parents' long-term care.  That's because more than half of U.S. states have so-called filial responsibility laws, which require adult children to provide financial support to their indigent parents. 

MEDICAID OUTLAYS

While the laws are rarely enforced, experts predict that the growth in the population of older people and increased Medicaid outlays will lead more nursing homes to rely on filial laws to get adult children to pay for their parents' care.  In 2012, the Superior Court of Pennsylvania upheld a lower court ruling requiring a man to pay nearly $93,000 for his mother's nursing home bill. Other states that enforce filial laws include North and South Dakota. “It could be a sleeping giant,” Charlie Douglas, a board member of the National Association of Estate Planners & Councils, was quoted as saying about the enforcement of filial laws in a recent InvestmentNews story. “Most people aren't even aware of filial responsibility laws.” If awakened, that sleeping giant may wreak havoc on the financial security of millions. A semi-private room in a nursing home averaged $6,235 per month in 2010, while a private room cost $6,965; and care in an assisted-living facility averaged $3,293 per month, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

THINKING AHEAD

Financial advisers owe it to their clients to make them aware of these filial laws. They should encourage them to think ahead about how much financial responsibility they're willing to assume for their aging parents. Many likely will say they'll do whatever it takes to ensure their parents are well cared for. They'll take out second mortgages, empty their childrens' college accounts or, worse, their 401(k)s. But for many, especially those with modest savings, such moves would put their own financial security in peril. That, in turn, likely would saddle their own children with the responsibility of paying for their retirement. 

EMOTIONAL MINEFIELD

Encouraging clients to balance their parents' financial needs with their own won't be easy. Even under the best of circumstances, the parent-child relationship is an emotional minefield. It is a financial adviser's job to help clients navigate that minefield.   Meanwhile, advisers and groups representing advisers should encourage state legislators to repeal or scale back filial laws. They are an anachronism, a vestige of English rule that addressed the widespread poverty of the 1600s. Today, with the advent of government programs such as welfare and Medicaid, filial laws are no longer needed.  What's more, such laws do not address the main problem: too many retirees are unprepared for decades of retirement.  If anything, adult children have a financial obligation to their children — not their parents. While taking care of ones' parents into old age may be the right and moral thing to do, it is not something that can — or should — be legislated.

Latest News

DeSantis unleashes ‘Florida DOGE’ in quest to kill property taxes
DeSantis unleashes ‘Florida DOGE’ in quest to kill property taxes

To help fund the proposal, the governor and Florida's finance chief are probing municipal finances on a "local government accountability tour" to uncover potential waste.

Edward Jones job cuts and buyouts hit 811 employees
Edward Jones job cuts and buyouts hit 811 employees

Edward Jones’ job cuts and overall realignment internally are contributing to higher costs for the company, it said in its recent quarterly report.

Advisor moves: LPL nabs $715M team from Cetera's Avantax community
Advisor moves: LPL nabs $715M team from Cetera's Avantax community

Meanwhile, Fifth Third's RIA arm adds a former billion-dollar BNY trio in Boulder, Colorado, while a hybrid RIA opens a new North Carolina location with a former Raymond James-affiliated team.

Tax compliance costs US economy over $536B, Tax Foundation finds
Tax compliance costs US economy over $536B, Tax Foundation finds

Analysis highlights swelling out-of-pocket costs and wasted time on paperwork, with an outsized toll on businesses and around crypto transactions.

Raymond James taps Allianz alum in continued push into ETF space
Raymond James taps Allianz alum in continued push into ETF space

The appointment to its investment management arm comes roughly a year after the firm first announced plans to launch its own exchange-traded fund platform.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.