NAFA files second lawsuit against DOL fiduciary rule

NAFA files second lawsuit against DOL fiduciary rule
The National Association for Fixed Annuities levies similar arguments to the initial suit, filed just one day earlier.
JUN 08, 2016
A leading insurance trade group has filed a second lawsuit aimed at striking down a Labor Department rule to raise investment advice standards in retirement accounts. The move Thursday by the National Association of Fixed Annuities comes one day after a group of financial and business trade groups filed a similar lawsuit against the rule that will have a profound effect on the way many financial advisers deliver retirement advice when it is implemented on April 2017. NAFA, a trade association representing insurance companies, independent marketing organizations and individual insurance agents, filed its lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. Aside from asking the court to vacate and set aside the fiduciary rule and its associated exemptions, NAFA is seeking a preliminary injunction, or a temporary halt that could delay the implementation date. Meeting the April 2017 deadline for initial implementation of the rule is "almost an impossibility for the industry," Chip Anderson, NAFA's executive director, said Friday NAFA levies six counts against defendants and uses similar arguments to the initial suit, which was filed Wednesday by a party of nine plaintiffs in a Texas district court, to challenge the Labor Department's co-called “fiduciary” rule. “The Department exceeded its statutory authority under ERISA and acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner in promulgating its new definitions of 'investment advice to a plan' and 'fiduciary,'” according to the complaint. The initial suit uses the same terminology — “arbitrary” and “capricious” — to attack the rule. Despite the similarities in language, the two suits are not part of a coordinated effort to block the rule, Mr. Anderson said. NAFA also attacks the DOL's extension of fiduciary obligations to individual retirement accounts, the private right of action created under the Best Interest Contract Exemption (BICE) portion of the rule, the “unduly” vagueness of the term “reasonable compensation” in the rule, the DOL's failure to consider the rule's impact on small businesses (particularly independent marketing organizations and insurance agents), and inclusion of fixed indexed annuities in the BICE. Whereas the initial suit, filed Wednesday, listed nine plaintiffs, NAFA is the sole plaintiff in the most recent legal challenge to the DOL's fiduciary rule. And like the first suit, Secretary of Labor Thomas Perez and the DOL are the named defendants. (Related read: The DOL Fiduciary rule from all angles) In response to the first lawsuit, Mr. Perez said “industry groups and lobbyists are suing for the right to put their own financial self-interests ahead of the best interests of their customers,” according to a statement. A spokesman for the DOL said on Friday that the department had no immediate comment on the second lawsuit. Proponents of the rule feel it's necessary to protect retirement savers from high-fee investment products that erode their nest eggs. Opponents believe the rule will lead to higher compliance costs and litigation risk, leading them to abandon some smaller retirement accounts. Observers have said there will likely be multiple legal challenges to the Labor Department's regulation, released in early April, with the most likely attackers being from the insurance lobby. The Insured Retirement Institute was a co-plaintiff in the first suit. The name of the second suit is The National Association for Fixed Annuities v. Thomas E. Perez et al.

Latest News

Judge OKs more than $90 million in settlement money for GWG investors
Judge OKs more than $90 million in settlement money for GWG investors

Mayer Brown, GWG's law firm, agreed to pay $30 million to resolve conflict of interest claims.

Fintech bytes: Orion and eMoney add new planning, investment tools for RIAs
Fintech bytes: Orion and eMoney add new planning, investment tools for RIAs

Orion adds new model portfolios and SMAs under expanded JPMorgan tie-up, while eMoney boosts its planning software capabilities.

Retirement uncertainty cuts across generations: Transamerica
Retirement uncertainty cuts across generations: Transamerica

National survey of workers exposes widespread retirement planning challenges for Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, and Boomers.

Does a merger or acquisition make sense for your firm? Why now is the perfect time to secure your firm’s future
Does a merger or acquisition make sense for your firm? Why now is the perfect time to secure your firm’s future

While the choice for advisors to "die at their desks" might been wise once upon a time, higher acquisition multiples and innovations in deal structures have created more immediate M&A opportunities.

Raymond James continues recruitment run with UBS, Morgan Stanley teams
Raymond James continues recruitment run with UBS, Morgan Stanley teams

A father-son pair has joined the firm's independent arm in Utah, while a quartet of planning advisors strengthen its employee channel in Louisiana.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave