Public pensions are significantly more progressive when it comes to supporting shareholder resolutions for ESG-themed funds, according to analysis by Morningstar.
Last year, there was a record 34% support for ESG resolutions at U.S. public companies. Public pensions voted in favor of ESG resolutions 90% of the time, while the ESG-focused mutual funds and ETFs supported those resolutions 85% of the time, on average, Morningstar found.
The report found six fund providers with higher rates of support for ESG votes than pensions: Amundi US (100%), Xtrackers (100%), Northern Funds (100%), Calvert (99%), American Century (99%) and TIAA/Nuveen (92%). Meanwhile, the report identified several big fund firms that lagged the ESG-focused funds average: BlackRock/iShares (74%), State Street (66%), Vanguard (51%) and Dimensional Fund Advisors (43%).
Compared with general shareholder votes, public pensions were much more likely to support resolutions around ESG governance (93% versus 43%) and worker protection (92% versus 51%), excluding vote results from company insider shareholders. The differences were less pronounced on diversity and inclusion (94% versus 73%) and climate change (86% versus 65%). The report analyzed data from 72 ESG shareholder resolutions in 2021, with results from a sample of the biggest public pensions in the country, representing about $3.4 trillion in assets, according to Morningstar. The report used 2021 data, rather than from the current proxy season, as pension plans often have a lag time in reporting how they voted.
This story was originally published on ESG Clarity.
Also, Orion has added BlackRock, Fidelity, and Vanguard to its custom portfolios suite, and RedBlack has set up a new headquarters after crossing a trillion-dollar milestone.
Also, New York-based Legacy Edge Advisors names its first-ever CEO, while Novare Capital Management hires a Vanguard veteran with a multigenerational planning focus.
Asset managers are racing to bring private market products to retirement plans, but cost and liquidity concerns linger.
Treasury's latest tax-exemption crackdown on private schools lands in the wake of a separate push to restrict refundable credits for some immigrant filers.
Workforce trust measures predicted which companies came out ahead during COVID-19. The same dynamic may now be playing out across the AI transition — and the data suggests the spread could be just as wide.
Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains
Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income
