SCOTUS vacates Northwestern rulings

SCOTUS vacates Northwestern rulings
In a decision that's almost certainly unwelcome news for retirement plan sponsors, the Supreme Court said lower courts paid too much attention to whether the university's inclusion of some low-cost options in its plans is sufficient to show fiduciaries abided by their duties.
JAN 24, 2022

Retirement plan sponsors everywhere Monday got what is almost certainly unwelcome news: The Supreme Court overturned lower courts' dismissals of a long-running case against Northwestern University.

The court ruled unanimously, excluding Justice Amy Comey Barrett, who did not participate, that the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals erred in its analysis that led it to uphold a dismissal granted by the district court.

In short, the lower courts paid too much attention to whether the Northwestern plans' inclusion of some low-cost options is sufficient to show the fiduciaries abided by their duties under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act.

“The Seventh Circuit’s exclusive focus on investor choice elided this aspect of the duty of prudence,” the order read. “The court maintained the same mistaken focus in rejecting petitioners’ claims with respect to record-keeping fees on the grounds that plan participants could have chosen investment options with lower expenses.”

The justices kicked the case back to the Seventh Circuit, directing the appellate judges to “reevaluate the allegations as a whole, considering whether petitioners have plausibly alleged a violation of the duty of prudence as articulated in Tibble under applicable pleading standards.”

Several years ago, the Supreme Court found in the landmark Tibble v. Edison International case that plan fiduciaries have an ongoing duty to monitor plan investments.

In the Northwestern case, which was filed in 2016, the plaintiffs alleged that the school ran afoul of ERISA by opting for investment options and plan services with higher-than-necessary fees.

“In rejecting petitioners’ allegations, the Seventh Circuit did not apply Tibble’s guidance but instead erroneously focused on another component of the duty of prudence: a fiduciary’s obligation to assemble a diverse menu of options,” today’s order read. “But respondents’ provision of an adequate array of investment choices, including the lower cost investments plaintiffs wanted, does not excuse their allegedly imprudent decisions.”

The case against Northwestern, similar to numerous other lawsuits brought in recent years against 401(k) and 403(b) plan sponsors, has relied on the fact that cheaper options were available than those used within the plan. Whether that alone is sufficient to state a claim has been disputed in the case, and that detail is critical to litigators. Because plan committee meetings and notes are usually not public, prior to discovery, plaintiffs’ law firms have little or no direct insight into fiduciaries’ processes for selecting investments and services.

“At times, the circumstances facing an ERISA fiduciary will implicate difficult tradeoffs, and courts must give due regard to the range of reasonable judgments a fiduciary may make based on her experience and expertise,” the order read.

Latest News

Northern Trust names new West Region president for wealth
Northern Trust names new West Region president for wealth

The new regional leader brings nearly 25 years of experience as the firm seeks to tap a complex and evolving market.

Capital Group extends retirement plan services further with a focus on advisors
Capital Group extends retirement plan services further with a focus on advisors

The latest updates to its recordkeeping platform, including a solution originally developed for one large 20,000-advisor client, take aim at the small to medium-sized business space.

Why RIAs are the next growth frontier for annuities
Why RIAs are the next growth frontier for annuities

David Lau, founder and CEO of DPL Financial Partners, explains how the RIA boom and product innovation has fueled a slow-burn growth story in annuities.

Supreme Court slaps down challenge to IRS summons for Coinbase user data
Supreme Court slaps down challenge to IRS summons for Coinbase user data

Crypto investor argues the federal agency's probe, upheld by a federal appeals court, would "strip millions of Americans of meaningful privacy protections."

Houston-based RIA Americana Partners adds $1B+ with former Morgan Stanley director
Houston-based RIA Americana Partners adds $1B+ with former Morgan Stanley director

Meanwhile in Chicago, the wirehouse also lost another $454 million team as a group of defectors moved to Wells Fargo.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.