SEC rule proposal doesn't include 401(k) sponsors in 'best interest' advice

Plan sponsors are left out of the equation because they don't appear to fall within the definition of "retail" investor, legal experts say.
JUN 13, 2018

The Securities and Exchange Commission is trying to bridge the gap in investment advice standards for brokers and financial advisers, but the rift remains wide in one particular area: advice to 401(k) plan sponsors. The SEC proposed Regulation Best Interest in mid-April as part of a broader rulemaking package. It would up the ante for brokers interacting with several retirement-account stakeholders — for example, owners of individual retirement accounts, employees rolling money out of a retirement plan and 401(k) participants deciding how to invest their money in-plan. Instead of just having to choose investments that are suitable for clients, brokers would be held to a more-stringent "best interest" standard, which isn't specifically defined in the proposal. However, 401(k) plan sponsors are left out of the equation because they don't appear to fall within the SEC rule's definition of "retail" investor, according to legal experts. This omission would put brokers and RIAs on uneven footing, as they are today without the Labor Department's fiduciary rule, when giving advice to small-business owners about things such as their 401(k) investment lineups. They'd be held to different standards of care — fiduciary duty for RIAs, suitability for brokers — when offering similar services to employers, experts said. "The commission should clarify that the definition of retail customers include nonprofessional fiduciaries of retirement plans," Doug Fisher, director of retirement policy at the American Retirement Association, said in reference to small businesses sponsoring 401(k) plans. "Otherwise, what you have in an unlevel playing field," he said. "It feels like a gap." The American Retirement Association, an umbrella organization that includes the National Association of Plan Advisors trade group, plans to submit a comment letter to the SEC expressing this view, Mr. Fisher said. (More: 6 big questions about the SEC advice rule) The Department of Labor's fiduciary rule, which had turned brokers into fiduciaries when giving investment advice to 401(k) plans and participants, was overturned by the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in March. That decision is expected to become final any day. Broker-dealers beefed up their policies and procedures in anticipation of the DOL rule. That included receiving a flat fee for 401(k) services (instead of compensation like commissions and 12b-1 fees) and eliminating finder's fees that encouraged brokers to churn 401(k) plans (switch to a new plan provider in order to get another commission). Several firms also mandated that brokers unspecialized in the 401(k) market had to partner with more specialized advisers to deliver investment advice or outsource the advice to a third-party platform. Under the SEC proposal, it's possible some broker-dealers could revert to the pre-DOL-rule status quo relative to providing advice to 401(k) plan sponsors. "I think this is one of those areas where people will ask, 'What will happen with the marketplace?'" said Kevin Walsh, an attorney at Groom Law Group. However, Mr. Walsh said he'd be surprised if firms make changes, at least in the near term. The SEC may also plug the regulatory hole by the time a final rule is released, he said. Jason Roberts, chief executive of the Pension Resource Institute, said several measures broker-dealers put in place made it easier to supervise brokers, were more profitable and mitigated legal risk. Those measures will probably "stick," Mr. Roberts said, especially level-compensation platforms and additional training programs for brokers. Further, it would be hard to explain to examiners from the SEC or the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority Inc. why the firm clawed back new procedures to address practices it deemed high-risk, he said. "By walking away from a change designed to eliminate or mitigate conflict, I can't imagine explaining that to an SEC examiner," Mr. Roberts said.

Latest News

Judge OKs more than $90 million in settlement money for GWG investors
Judge OKs more than $90 million in settlement money for GWG investors

Mayer Brown, GWG's law firm, agreed to pay $30 million to resolve conflict of interest claims.

Fintech bytes: Orion and eMoney add new planning, investment tools for RIAs
Fintech bytes: Orion and eMoney add new planning, investment tools for RIAs

Orion adds new model portfolios and SMAs under expanded JPMorgan tie-up, while eMoney boosts its planning software capabilities.

Retirement uncertainty cuts across generations: Transamerica
Retirement uncertainty cuts across generations: Transamerica

National survey of workers exposes widespread retirement planning challenges for Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X, and Boomers.

Does a merger or acquisition make sense for your firm? Why now is the perfect time to secure your firm’s future
Does a merger or acquisition make sense for your firm? Why now is the perfect time to secure your firm’s future

While the choice for advisors to "die at their desks" might been wise once upon a time, higher acquisition multiples and innovations in deal structures have created more immediate M&A opportunities.

Raymond James continues recruitment run with UBS, Morgan Stanley teams
Raymond James continues recruitment run with UBS, Morgan Stanley teams

A father-son pair has joined the firm's independent arm in Utah, while a quartet of planning advisors strengthen its employee channel in Louisiana.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.

SPONSORED Beyond the dashboard: Making wealth tech human

How intelliflo aims to solve advisors' top tech headaches—without sacrificing the personal touch clients crave