Self-directed IRAs hold risks for financial advisers

NASAA warning highlights need for advisers to know the ins and outs of these accounts.
NOV 30, 2014
The year-end tax savings crunch is here. Better make sure your clients don't get snared in a self-directed IRA scam. The North American Securities Administrators Association on Monday warned investors about the fact and fiction behind the duties of third-party custodians who handle self-directed individual retirement accounts. Though the warning is targeted toward investors, advisers should also listen up. “If an adviser recommends that [I add] to my self-directed IRA, then he should have done his homework: He should know what is in it and check it out,” said Joseph Borg, director of the Alabama Securities Commission, one of NASAA's state securities regulator jurisdictions. That due diligence responsibility applies when advisers inherit a self-directed IRA account after bringing on a client, he added. “Think of the third-party IRA custodian as the safe-deposit box: If phony stuff goes in there, it's still phony,” Mr. Borg said. Self-directed IRAs tend to be the domain of nontraditional assets, including real estate, metals and business ventures. These accounts also have been the subject of regulatory scrutiny and punitive action as some investors have found themselves with complex investments and no idea of what they're worth. Investors also think the third-party custodians providing the self-directed IRA are blessing the investments that are available, performing due diligence and monitoring the clients' accounts. One popular myth NASAA hopes to dispel is that the investment in a self-directed IRA is safe because the third-party custodian is a regulated trust company. In reality, the custodian is approved by the Internal Revenue Service, but its only real duty is to report contributions to and distributions from the account. Clients also believe that the third-party custodian is holding the investment assets, when it's just a keeper of deposits and distributions from the account, according to NASAA. “The custodian is a safe-deposit-box operator,” Mr. Borg said. NASAA's warning comes at a special time of year. “You have the end of the year: The tax season is coming up, and people are looking at how much they've put away [for retirement],” Mr. Borg said. “But the big problem is the fraudsters who want you to invest in the next big oil drilling program and who'll say that it's an IRS-approved investment.”

Latest News

Carson Group adds $405M Northwestern Mutual team in Atlanta
Carson Group adds $405M Northwestern Mutual team in Atlanta

Yari Capital's move to Carson continues a run of additions for the $62 billion firm, days after it hired a veteran recruiter from Osaic.

Wealth Enhancement inks 'coming home' deal with Oklahoma RIA
Wealth Enhancement inks 'coming home' deal with Oklahoma RIA

Servo Wealth Management's $210 million book brings the Minneapolis consolidator's total client assets further past $160 billion.

Omaha-based RIA Stevens Capital Partners nears $1B, buys Dallas CPA firm
Omaha-based RIA Stevens Capital Partners nears $1B, buys Dallas CPA firm

The deal to acquire a 300-client tax firm sets up much-needed succession for its 80-year-old founder, while joining a widening trend of tax service integration among RIAs.

Most Americans oblivious to Social Security’s projected demise
Most Americans oblivious to Social Security’s projected demise

New Nationwide Retirement Institute survey reveals eight in ten Americans agree Social Security needs fixing and how.

NewEdge advisors reshape client work with AI in weeks after Anthropic rollout
NewEdge advisors reshape client work with AI in weeks after Anthropic rollout

Advisor-led adoption has been rapid for tasks from translating annuity contracts into plain English to speedy webinar prep.

SPONSORED Direct indexing webinar targets tax-loss harvesting amid market swings

Northern Trust’s Ken Lassner shows advisors how to convert volatility into after-tax portfolio gains

SPONSORED Who builds the income when the pension disappears?

Dan Biagini of American Equity says the steady decline of pensions, longer lifespans and a reset in interest rates are rewriting how advisors build retirement income