Tax reform anomaly could diminish some companies' need for 401(k) plan

A dichotomy in the tax treatment of retirement deferrals and business income could discourage creation, maintenance of plans by some pass-through entities.
SEP 28, 2017

The Republican tax-reform framework released Wednesday has led to concern within some retirement industry circles that plan creation and maintenance — and plan advisers' businesses — would be negatively impacted by its policy details. The template, issued by the Trump administration and congressional committees to help guide a rewrite of the nation's tax code in the coming months, would dissuade some business owners from having a 401(k) plan due to a dichotomy in the tax treatment of business income versus savings, observers argue. Pass-through entities, whose income is reported on business owners' individual tax returns, would be taxed at a maximum rate of 25%. However, the deferred 401(k) savings of those same wealthy business owners would be taxed at 35%, the top marginal tax bracket identified in the Republican framework. Brian Graff, chief executive of the American Retirement Association, said this 10% difference amounts to a "tax penalty" on deferred retirement savings, and would make paying the tax up front more appealing. "There's never any financial scenario where it makes sense to defer at that point," said Mr. Graff, also executive direction of the National Association of Plan Advisers. The value of a retirement deferral is contingent on tax rates matching on the front and back ends of a retirement plan, he said. Mr. Graff questioned why a business owner would opt to pay a "penalty" on retirement deferrals, maintain fiduciary liability for sponsoring a 401(k) plan and assume the administrative costs. "We can't let this fall under the radar, otherwise there's no reason for these business owners to have a retirement plan anymore," Mr. Graff said. "No plans, no need for an adviser." (More: 'Rothification' to pay for tax cuts seen as losing momentum, for now) Pass-through entities, which include businesses structured as sole proprietorships, partnerships, limited liability companies and S Corporations, represent 90% of U.S. businesses and are responsible for more than half of private-sector jobs in the country, according to a Tax Foundation analysis. However, a survey published this year by the Pew Charitable Trusts shows that while taxes do factor into employers' reasoning for offering a retirement plan, it's not necessarily the determining reason. Nearly 60% of the 1,600 small and midsize employers surveyed indicated providing tax advantages for company management was a reason for offering a plan, but that was fourth in line behind helping employees save for retirement, having a positive impact on employee performance, and helping attract and retain employees. Only 5% said it was the main reason for offering a plan. "Do tax advantages matter? Sure. But there's a constellation of reasons why business owners offer a retirement plan, and I think we need to look at this issue more holistically," said John Scott, director of retirement savings at Pew. Aaron Pottichen, retirement services practice leader at advisory firm CLS Partners, doesn't believe the disparity in tax rates would dissuade most business owners from sponsoring a 401(k) plan. The argument, he said, presupposes an individual would be in the 35% marginal tax rate in retirement; however, many individuals' income in retirement is often less, roughly 60-70% of their pre-retirement income, he said. "At the end of the day, ultimately if someone is determining whether they should save in a 401(k) or not, that should be based on the financial plan, not tax incentives," Mr. Pottichen said.

Latest News

RIA moves: The Mather Group, Brand Asset Management announce deals
RIA moves: The Mather Group, Brand Asset Management announce deals

Consolidation continues in US wealth management industry.

US broker-dealer fintech aims for global footprint as it acquires international firm
US broker-dealer fintech aims for global footprint as it acquires international firm

Tech company democratizes access to US trading infrastructure.

Advisor moves: RBC swipes $1.7B UBS team, Baird duo departs for LPL's Linsco channel
Advisor moves: RBC swipes $1.7B UBS team, Baird duo departs for LPL's Linsco channel

RBC Wealth Management's latest move in New York adds an elite eight-member team to its recently opened Westchester office.

Stifel star broker, Chuck Roberts, leaves firm under cloud of investor complaints
Stifel star broker, Chuck Roberts, leaves firm under cloud of investor complaints

Stifel – so far - is on the hook for more than $166 million in damages, legal fees and settlements in investor complaints involving Roberts, a 35-year industry veteran.

iCapital secures $820M in latest funding, hits $7.5B
iCapital secures $820M in latest funding, hits $7.5B

The giant alt investments platform's latest financing led by T. Rowe Price and SurgoCap Partners, along with State Street, UBS, and BNY, will fuel additional growth on multiple fronts.

SPONSORED How advisors can build for high-net-worth complexity

Orion's Tom Wilson on delivering coordinated, high-touch service in a world where returns alone no longer set you apart.

SPONSORED RILAs bring stability, growth during volatile markets

Barely a decade old, registered index-linked annuities have quickly surged in popularity, thanks to their unique blend of protection and growth potential—an appealing option for investors looking to chart a steadier course through today's choppy market waters, says Myles Lambert, Brighthouse Financial.